Below is a listing of all of the nominees for RTCC awards since 2008. Data has been normalized to the best of our ability.
A full listing of members of a production’s ensemble is not yet available for productions nominated for Best Ensemble.
Nominees List
| nominee | production | category | company | year | win |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brett Ambler | Urinetown | Best Actor / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | |
| Ford Flanagan | Peter Pan | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Scott Wichmann | Guys & Dolls | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2008 | Y |
| Andy Boothby | Mr. Marmalade | Best Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2008 | |
| Duke Lafoon | Doubt: A Parable | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Frank Creasy | The Spanish Tragedy | Best Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2008 | |
| J. Ron Fleming | A Lesson Before Dying | Best Actor / Play | AART | 2008 | |
| Justin Dray | The Late Henry Moss | Best Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2008 | Y |
| Angela Shipley | Urinetown | Best Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | |
| Audra Honaker | Once Upon A Mattress | Best Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | Y |
| Nancy McMahon | The Two Svengalis | Best Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2008 | |
| Rachel Abrams | Guys & Dolls | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Irene Zeigler | Doubt: A Parable | Best Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2008 | Y |
| Katie McCall | Spinning Into Butter | Best Actress / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2008 | |
| Margarette Joyner | From the Mississippi Delta | Best Actress / Play | AART | 2008 | |
| Susan Sanford | The Little Dog Laughed | Best Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Terry Menefee Gau | A Streetcar Named Desire | Best Actress / Play | Sycamore Rouge | 2008 | |
| Brandon Becker | Urinetown | Best Choreography | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | Y |
| Leslie Owens-Harrington | Peter Pan | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Patti D'Beck | Guys & Dolls | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Jase Smith | Reefer Madness | Best Direction / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2008 | |
| Patti D'Beck | Guys & Dolls | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Steve Perigard | Peter Pan | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Tom Width | Urinetown | Best Direction / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | Y |
| Andrew Hamm | As You Like It (indoor) | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2008 | |
| Bruce Miller | The Little Dog Laughed | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2008 | Y |
| James Ricks | Richard II | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2008 | |
| Keri Wormald | Doubt: A Parable | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Morrie Piersol | The Late Henry Moss | Best Direction / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2008 | |
| Guys & Dolls | Guys & Dolls | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Peter Pan | Peter Pan | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Reefer Madness | Reefer Madness | Best Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2008 | |
| Urinetown | Urinetown | Best Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | Y |
| Leilani Mork | Reefer Madness | Best Musical Direction | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2008 | |
| Paul Deiss | Plaid Tidings | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | |
| Paul Deiss | Urinetown | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | |
| Sandy Dacus | Guys and Dolls | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| As You Like It (indoor) | As You Like It (indoor) | Best Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2008 | |
| Doubt: A Parable | Doubt: A Parable | Best Play | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Spinning Into Butter | Spinning Into Butter | Best Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2008 | |
| The Late Henry Moss | The Late Henry Moss | Best Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2008 | Y |
| The Little Dog Laughed | The Little Dog Laughed | Best Play | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Chris Hester | Reefer Madness | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2008 | |
| Jason Marks | Guys & Dolls | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2008 | Y |
| Richard Koch | Rumpelstiltskin's Daughter | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Robert Throckmorton | Peter Pan | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Scott Melton | Urinetown | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | |
| David Bridgewater | Henry IV, Part 2 | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2008 | |
| Dean Knight | The Seagull | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2008 | |
| Joseph Anthony Carlson | Henry IV, Part 2 | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2008 | |
| Stephen Ryan | Richard II | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2008 | Y |
| Toney Cobb | Charcoal Street | Best Supporting Actor / Play | AART | 2008 | |
| Audra Honaker | Urinetown | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | |
| Debra Wagoner | Urinetown | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | Y |
| Joy Newsome | Reefer Madness | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2008 | |
| Joy Williams | Once Upon A Mattress | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | |
| Jennie Meharg | The Late Henry Moss | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2008 | Y |
| Katherine Louis | Member of the Wedding | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Laine Satterfield | The Little Dog Laughed | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Liz Blake White | Measure for Measure | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2008 | |
| Chris Mueller | The Seagull | Costume Design | Henley Street | 2008 | |
| Elizabeth Weiss Hopper | Member of the Wedding | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Maura Lynch Cravey | Urinetown | Costume Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | |
| Rebecca Cairns | As You Like It (indoor) | Costume Design | Richmond Shakespeare | 2008 | Y |
| Sue Griffin | Peter Pan | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Joe Doran | Urinetown | Lighting Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2008 | Y |
| Lynne Hartman | Member of the Wedding | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Lynne Hartman | The Little Dog Laughed | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Matthew Landwehr | A Christmas Story | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Liz Marks | Liz Marks | 2008 | Y | ||
| Murdered By The Mob | Mystery Dinner Theatre | Notable Interactive Prod | Mystery Dinner Theatre | 2008 | |
| Richmond Improv Festival | ComedySportz | Notable Interactive Prod | ComedySportz | 2008 | Y |
| Stories of Egypt | Carpenter Science Theatre | Notable Interactive Prod | Carpenter Science Theatre | 2008 | |
| Brian Barker | The Member of the Wedding | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Brian Kalin | The Little Dog Laughed | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Greig Leach | Peter Pan | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Mercedes Schaum | A Christmas Story | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2008 | |
| Ron Keller | Guys and Dolls | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2008 | Y |
| Brett Ambler | tick, tick¿Boom! | Best Actor / Musical | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Christopher Stewart | Summer of '42 | Best Actor / Musical | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Gordon Bass | Annie | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Paul Valley | The Great American Trailer Park Musical | Best Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Zak Resnick | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2009 | Y |
| David Clark | True West | Best Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2009 | |
| Joe Inscoe | Eurydice | Best Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | Y |
| Landon Nagel | Children of a Lesser God | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Scott Wichmann | Richard III | Best Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2009 | |
| Tony Foley | True West | Best Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2009 | |
| Angela Shipley (w/ Robyn O'Neill) | Side Show | Best Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Audra Honaker | tick, tick¿Boom! | Best Actress / Musical | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | Y |
| Joy Williams | Annie | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Kim Jones Clark | The Great American Trailer Park Musical | Best Actress / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Maggie Marlin | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Robyn O'Neill (w/ Angela Shipley) | Side Show | Best Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Bianca Bryan | The Clean House | Best Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Erica Siegel | Children of a Lesser God | Best Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Jody Smith Strickler | Well | Best Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Laine Satterfield | Eurydice | Best Actress / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Robin Arthur | The Clean House | Best Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2009 | Y |
| Mickey Nugent | Altar Boyz | Best Choreography | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Patti D'Beck | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2009 | Y |
| Robin Arthur | Annie | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Chase Kniffen | Children's Letters to God | Best Direction / Musical | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Chase Kniffen | tick, tick¿Boom! | Best Direction / Musical | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Patti D'Beck | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2009 | Y |
| Robin Arthur | Annie | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Tom Width | Altar Boyz | Best Direction / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Bo Wilson | True West | Best Direction / Play | Henley Street | 2009 | |
| Bruce Miller | Children of a Lesser God | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Keri Wormald | Well | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Rusty Wilson | Eurydice | Best Direction / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | Y |
| Steve Perigard | The Clean House | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| A Midsummer Night's Dream | A Midsummer Night's Dream | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Shakespeare | 2009 | Y |
| Altar Boyz | Altar Boyz | Best Ensemble Acting | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Children's Letters to God | Children's Letters to God | Best Ensemble Acting | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Driving Miss Daisy | Driving Miss Daisy | Best Ensemble Acting | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| The Great American Trailer Park Musical | The Great American Trailer Park Musical | Best Ensemble Acting | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Altar Boyz | Altar Boyz | Best Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Annie | Annie | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| The Great American Trailer Park Musical | The Great American Trailer Park Musical | Best Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Thoroughly Modern Millie | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2009 | Y |
| tick, tick¿Boom! | tick, tick¿Boom! | Best Musical | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Jimmy Hicks | Children's Letters to God | Best Musical Direction | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Paul Deiss | Altar Boyz | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Paul Deiss | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2009 | Y |
| Sandy Dacus | tick, tick¿Boom! | Best Musical Direction | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Tony Williams | Summer of '42 | Best Musical Direction | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Children of a Lesser God | Children of a Lesser God | Best Play | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Eurydice | Eurydice | Best Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | Y |
| The Clean House | The Clean House | Best Play | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| True West | True West | Best Play | Henley Street | 2009 | |
| Well | Well | Best Play | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Chris Hester | The Great American Trailer Park Musical | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Christopher Hlusko | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Drew Seigla | Summer of '42 | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Sean Williams | Altar Boyz | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Timothy Ford | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2009 | Y |
| Brandon Crowder | One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2009 | |
| Larry Cook | Eurydice | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | Y |
| Michael Hawke | Arsenic & Old Lace | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Richard Gregory | Children of a Lesser God | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Steve Moore | One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2009 | |
| Ali Thibodeau | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2009 | Y |
| Ellie Atwood | Summer of '42 | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Linda Poser | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Maggie Roop | Annie | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Nancy McMahon | The Great American Trailer Park Musical | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Elise Boyd | Inspecting Carol | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Sycamore Rouge | 2009 | |
| Jacqueline Jones (with Jolene Carroll) | Arsenic & Old Lace | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Jan Guarino | The Clean House | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Jolene Carroll (with Jackie Jones) | Arsenic & Old Lace | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Marta Rainer | Rabbit Hole | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | Y |
| Stefani Zabner | Of Mice and Men | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Ann Hoskins (w/ Rebecca Cairns) | Henry V | Costume Design | Richmond Shakespeare | 2009 | |
| Betty Williams (w/ Charlotte Schiff) | All My Sons | Costume Design | Chamberlayne Actors Theatre | 2009 | |
| Charlotte Schiff (w/ Betty Williams) | All My Sons | Costume Design | Chamberlayne Actors Theatre | 2009 | |
| Elizabeth Weiss Hopper | Sideways Stories from Wayside School | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Rebecca Cairns (w/ Ann Hoskins) | Henry V | Costume Design | Richmond Shakespeare | 2009 | |
| Sue Griffin | The Clean House | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Sue Griffin | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2009 | Y |
| Amanda Durst | The Clean House | Dialect Direction | Virginia Rep | 2009 | Y |
| Vanessa Passini | Henry V | Fight Choreography | Richmond Shakespeare | 2009 | Y |
| Andrew Boothby (w/Jenny Hundley & Lauren Leinhaus-Cook) | Eurydice | Hair / Makeup Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Elizabeth Weiss Hopper | Sideways Stories from Wayside School | Hair / Makeup Design | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Jenny Hundley (w/Andrew Boothby & Lauren Leinhaus-Cook) | Eurydice | Hair / Makeup Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Junior Oxendine | Pulp | Hair / Makeup Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2009 | |
| Lauren Leinhaus-Cook (w/ Andrew Boothby & Jenny Hundley) | Eurydice | Hair / Makeup Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Sarah Grady | Annie | Hair / Makeup Design | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Sue Griffin | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Hair / Makeup Design | Virginia Rep | 2009 | Y |
| Joe Doran | Altar Boyz | Lighting Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | Y |
| Joe Doran | Of Mice and Men | Lighting Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Kenny Mullens | Children's Letters to God | Lighting Design | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Kenny Mullens | Summer of '42 | Lighting Design | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Lynne Hartman | The Clean House | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Lou Rubin | Liz Marks | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | Y | |
| Warren "Buddy" Callahan | Liz Marks | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | Y | |
| Brian Barker | Sideways Stories from Wayside School | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Keith Saine | Translations | Set Design | Sycamore Rouge | 2009 | |
| Lin Heath | All My Sons | Set Design | Chamberlayne Actors Theatre | 2009 | |
| Mercedes Schaum | Summer of '42 | Set Design | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Phil Hayes | Eurydice | Set Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Ron Keller | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2009 | Y |
| Tom Width | Of Mice and Men | Set Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2009 | |
| Bryan Harris | Eurydice | Sound Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2009 | Y |
| Buddy Bishop | Chapter Two | Sound Design | Chamberlayne Actors Theatre | 2009 | |
| Derek Dumais | Sideways Stories from Wayside School | Sound Design | Virginia Rep | 2009 | |
| Derome Scott Smith | From the Mississippi Delta | Sound Design | AART | 2009 | |
| Wendy Vandergrift | Summer of '42 | Sound Design | Stage 1 Theatre Company | 2009 | |
| Durron Tyre | Rent | Best Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2010 | Y |
| Eric Stallings | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Ford Flanagan | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Joe Inscoe | A Christmas Carol | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Jonathan Spivey | Souvenir | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Jeffrey Cole | The Crucible | Best Actor / Play | Sycamore Rouge | 2010 | |
| Joe Inscoe | Shining City | Best Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2010 | Y |
| Matt Hackman | Take Me Out | Best Actor / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | |
| Matthew Bloch | Butterflies Are Free | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Richard Koch | Servant of Two Masters | Best Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2010 | |
| Robert Zukerman | Sex, Drugs, Rock and Roll | Best Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2010 | |
| Ronnie Brown | Take Me Out | Best Actor / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | |
| Aly Wepplo | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Debra Wagoner | Souvenir | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Joy Newsome | Rent | Best Actress / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2010 | Y |
| Lauren Leinhaas-Cook | Scrooge in Rouge | Best Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | |
| Stacey Cabaj | The Sound of Music | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Cynde Liffick | Elizabeth Rex | Best Actress / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2010 | |
| Jennie Meharg | A Doll's House | Best Actress / Play | Henley Street | 2010 | |
| Kelly Kennedy | On Golden Pond | Best Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2010 | Y |
| Melissa Johnston Price | Facing East | Best Actress / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | |
| Patricia Duran | Boleros for the Disenchanted | Best Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Ana Ines King | Boleros for the Disenchanted | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Maggie Marlin | Rent | Best Choreography | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2010 | |
| Willie Hilton | Black Nativity | Best Choreography | AART / VA Rep | 2010 | Y |
| Chase Kniffen | A Christmas Carol | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Chase Kniffen | The Sound of Music | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | Y |
| John Glenn | Souvenir | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Shon Stacy | Scrooge in Rouge | Best Direction / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | |
| Steve Perigard | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Bo Wilson | Shining City | Best Direction / Play | Henley Street | 2010 | Y |
| Bruce Miller | Boleros for the Disenchanted | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| James Ricks | Servant of Two Masters | Best Direction / Play | Henley Street | 2010 | |
| Julie Fulcher-Davis | Facing East | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | |
| Scott Wichmann | Take Me Out | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | |
| A Doll's House | A Doll's House | Best Ensemble Acting | Henley Street | 2010 | |
| Crowns | Crowns | Best Ensemble Acting | AART / VA Rep | 2010 | |
| Jar the Floor | Jar the Floor | Best Ensemble Acting | Sycamore Rouge | 2010 | |
| The Crucible | The Crucible | Best Ensemble Acting | Sycamore Rouge | 2010 | |
| The Mystery of Irma Vep | The Mystery of Irma Vep | Best Ensemble Acting | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2010 | Y |
| Rent | Rent | Best Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2010 | |
| Scrooge in Rouge | Scrooge in Rouge | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | |
| Souvenir | Souvenir | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| The Sound of Music | The Sound of Music | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | Y |
| Deborah Lynch | Scrooge in Rouge | Best Musical Direction | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | |
| Jason Marks | A Christmas Carol | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Leilani Mork | Rent | Best Musical Direction | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2010 | Y |
| R.L. Rowsey | Souvenir | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Sandy Dacus | The Sound of Music | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Boleros for the Disenchanted (Barksdale) | Boleros for the Disenchanted | Best Play | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Fool for Love | Fool for Love | Best Play | Cadence | 2010 | |
| Servant of Two Masters | Servant of Two Masters | Best Play | Henley Street | 2010 | |
| Shining City | Shining City | Best Play | Henley Street | 2010 | |
| Take Me Out | Take Me Out | Best Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | Y |
| Antonio Tillman | Rent | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2010 | Y |
| David Janeski | A Christmas Carol | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Matt Shofner | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Michael Hawke | The Sound of Music | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Steve Bochen | Scrooge in Rouge | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | |
| Eric Williams | Bus Stop | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Gordon Bass | Fool for Love | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Cadence | 2010 | |
| Jimmy Glidden | Take Me Out | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | Y |
| Joe Pabst | Is He Dead? | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Larry Cook | Shining City | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2010 | |
| Audra Honaker | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Debra Wagoner | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Jaci Camden | Rent | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2010 | |
| Kara Harmon | The Sound of Music | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Susan Sanford | The Sound of Music | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2010 | Y |
| Carmen Zilles | Boleros for the Disenchanted | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2010 | Y |
| Christina Bellew | Servant of Two Masters | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Henley Street | 2010 | |
| Jacqueline Jones | New Century | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | |
| Jodi Strickler | Greetings | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2010 | |
| Maggie Marlin | Boy's Life | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2010 | |
| Ann Hoskins (w/ Rebecca Cairns) | Twelfth Night | Costume Design | Richmond Shakespeare | 2010 | |
| Lindy Bumgarner | The Crucible | Costume Design | Sycamore Rouge | 2010 | |
| Rebecca Cairns | Servant of Two Masters | Costume Design | Henley Street | 2010 | Y |
| Rebecca Cairns (w/ Ann Hoskins) | Twelfth Night | Costume Design | Richmond Shakespeare | 2010 | |
| Sarah Grady | The Sound of Music | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Sue Griffin | Souvenir | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Brittany Diliberto | The Crucible | Lighting Design | Sycamore Rouge | 2010 | |
| David McLain | Sex, Drugs, Rock and Roll | Lighting Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2010 | |
| Joe Doran | Mystery of Irma Vep | Lighting Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2010 | |
| Lynne Hartman | The Sound of Music | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2010 | Y |
| Lynne Hartman | Boleros for the Disenchanted | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Neil and Sara Belle November | Liz Marks | 2010 | Y | ||
| A Christmas Carol (Theatre IV) | A Christmas Carol (Theatre IV) | Locally-Developed Work | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Full Plate Collection | Full Plate Collection | Locally-Developed Work | Independent | 2010 | Y |
| Jack in the Beanstalk | Jack in the Beanstalk | Locally-Developed Work | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Song of Mulan | Song of Mulan | Locally-Developed Work | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Betsy Muller | Is He Dead? | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2010 | Y |
| Brian Barker | Boleros for the Disenchanted | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Brian Barker | The Sound of Music | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| David Powers (w/ Terrie Powers) | On Golden Pond | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Eric Kinder | I'm Not Rappaport | Set Design | Chamberlayne Actors Theatre | 2010 | |
| Keith Saine | The Crucible | Set Design | Sycamore Rouge | 2010 | |
| Terrie Powers (w/ David Powers) | On Golden Pond | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Brett Zwerdling | Servant of Two Masters | Sound Design | Henley Street | 2010 | |
| Derek Dumais | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | Sound Design | Virginia Rep | 2010 | |
| Derek Dumais | The Sound of Music | Sound Design | Virginia Rep | 2010 | Y |
| Julie Fulcher-Davis | Take Me Out | Sound Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2010 | |
| Steve Organ | Sex, Drugs, Rock and Roll | Sound Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2010 | |
| Chris Hester | [title of show] | Best Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | |
| Daniel Cimo | [title of show] | Best Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | |
| Durron Tyre | Once on this Island | Best Actor / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| Jeff McCarthy | Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Scott Wichmann | Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2011 | Y |
| Alan Sader | King Lear | Best Actor / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2011 | Y |
| Billy Christopher Maupin | Something Intangible | Best Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2011 | |
| David Clark | Last Days of Judas Iscariot | Best Actor / Play | Henley / RTP | 2011 | |
| Joe Inscoe | Shipwrecked | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Larry Cook | Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? | Best Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2011 | |
| Georgia Rogers Farmer | [title of show] | Best Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | |
| Kris Roberts | Once on this Island | Best Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| Lanaya Burnette | [title of show] | Best Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | |
| Michelle Lookadoo | White Christmas | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Rachel Abrams | Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2011 | Y |
| Aly Wepplo | Wait Until Dark | Best Actress / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| Jennie Meharg | Arcadia | Best Actress / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2011 | |
| Laine Satterfield | Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? | Best Actress / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2011 | Y |
| Molly Hood | Oleanna | Best Actress / Play | Cadence | 2011 | |
| Tamara Johnson | Legacy of Light | Best Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Eugene Fleming (w/ Willie Hinton & LaWanda Raines) | Langston is my Man | Best Choreography | AART | 2011 | |
| LaWanda Raines (w/ Willie Hinton & Eugene Fleming) | Langston is my Man | Best Choreography | AART | 2011 | |
| Leslie Owens-Harrington | Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2011 | Y |
| Leslie Owens-Harrington | Godspell | Best Choreography | Cadence | 2011 | |
| Leslie Owens-Harrington | Once on this Island | Best Choreography | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| Patti D'Beck | White Christmas | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Willie Hinton (w/ LaWanda Raines & Eugene Fleming) | Langston is my Man | Best Choreography | AART | 2011 | |
| Chase Kniffen | Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2011 | Y |
| John Knapp | This Beautiful City | Best Direction / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | |
| Justin Amellio | [title of show] | Best Direction / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | |
| Patti D'Beck | White Christmas | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Tom Width | Once on this Island | Best Direction / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| Bo Wilson | Last Days of Judas Iscariot | Best Direction / Play | Henley / RTP | 2011 | |
| Derome Scott Smith | Jitney | Best Direction / Play | AART | 2011 | |
| James Alexander Bond | King Lear | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2011 | |
| John Moon | Shipwrecked | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Rusty Wilson | Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? | Best Direction / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2011 | Y |
| Jitney | Jitney | Best Ensemble Acting | AART | 2011 | Y |
| Nunsense | Nunsense | Best Ensemble Acting | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Pirates of the Chemotherapy | Pirates of the Chemotherapy | Best Ensemble Acting | Independent | 2011 | |
| Quilters | Quilters | Best Ensemble Acting | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| This Beautiful City | This Beautiful City | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | |
| [title of show] | [title of show] | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | |
| Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2011 | Y |
| Godspell | Godspell | Best Musical | Cadence | 2011 | |
| Once on this Island | Once on this Island | Best Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| This Beautiful City | This Beautiful City | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | |
| Drew Perkins | Smoke on the Mountain Homecoming | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Kim Fox | This Beautiful City | Best Musical Direction | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | |
| Leilani Mork | White Christmas | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Paul Deiss | Once on this Island | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| Sandy Dacus | Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2011 | Y |
| Jitney | Jitney | Best Play | AART | 2011 | |
| King Lear | King Lear | Best Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2011 | |
| Last Days of Judas Iscariot | Last Days of Judas Iscariot | Best Play | Henley / RTP | 2011 | Y |
| Legacy of Light | Legacy of Light | Best Play | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? | Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? | Best Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2011 | |
| Andrew Hamm | This Beautiful City | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | Y |
| Eric Williams | Smoke on the Mountain Homecoming | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| James Opher | Once on this Island | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| Joe Pabst | Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Matt Shofner | You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2011 | |
| Adrian Rieder | King Lear | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2011 | |
| Charley Raintree | King Lear | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2011 | |
| Foster Solomon | King Lear | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2011 | |
| J. Ron Fleming | Jitney | Best Supporting Actor / Play | AART | 2011 | Y |
| Ronnie Brown | Last Days of Judas Iscariot | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Henley / RTP | 2011 | |
| Debra Wagoner | Nunsense | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Kathy Halenda | White Christmas | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2011 | Y |
| Lanaya Burnette | This Beautiful City | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | |
| Nicole Oberleitner | Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Tarnee Kendell-Hudson | This Beautiful City | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | |
| Amy Sproul | Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2011 | |
| Debra Clinton | The Winter's Tale | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Henley Street | 2011 | |
| Jill Bari Steinberg | Last Days of Judas Iscariot | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Henley / RTP | 2011 | |
| Maggie Horan | Legacy of Light | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2011 | Y |
| Susan Sanford | Boeing Boeing | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Ann Hoskins (w/ Rebecca Cairns) | King Lear | Costume Design | Richmond Shakespeare | 2011 | |
| J. Theresa Bush | Legacy of Light | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2011 | Y |
| Maura Lynch Cravey | Once on this Island | Costume Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| Rebecca Cairns (w/ Ann Hoskins) | King Lear | Costume Design | Richmond Shakespeare | 2011 | |
| Shannon Bohn McCalister | Last Days of Judas Iscariot | Costume Design | Henley / RTP | 2011 | |
| Sue Griffin | Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Andrew Bonniwell | The Winter's Tale | Lighting Design | Henley Street | 2011 | |
| Joe Doran | Once on this Island | Lighting Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| Joe Doran | Quilters | Lighting Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| Lynne Hartman | Legacy of Light | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2011 | Y |
| Lynne Hartman | Shipwrecked | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Don Warren & Jay McCullough | Liz Marks | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | Y | |
| Michael Gooding | Liz Marks | Richmond Triangle Players | 2011 | Y | |
| Terry Snyder | Puppetry | 2011 | Y | ||
| Betsy Muller | Legacy of Light | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Brian Barker | Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2011 | Y |
| Phil Hayes | Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? | Set Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2011 | |
| Ron Keller | White Christmas | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Tom Width | Once on this Island | Set Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| Derek Dumais | Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Sound Design | Virginia Rep | 2011 | |
| Derek Dumais | White Christmas | Sound Design | Virginia Rep | 2011 | Y |
| Kim Fox (w/ Zachary Townsend & Shannon Marie) | Godspell | Sound Design | Cadence | 2011 | |
| Paul Deiss | Quilters | Sound Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2011 | |
| Rusty Wilson | Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? | Sound Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2011 | |
| Shannon Marie (w/ Zachary Townsend & Kim Fox) | Godspell | Sound Design | Cadence | 2011 | |
| Zachary Townsend (w/ Kim Fox & Shannon Marie) | Godspell | Sound Design | Cadence | 2011 | |
| Fernando Rivadeneira | Musical of Musicals | Best Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2012 | |
| Joe Inscoe | My Fair Lady | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| John Mincks | Spring Awakening | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Oliver Houser | Spring Awakening | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Terence Sullivan | Rocky Horror Show | Best Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | Y |
| Alan Sader | Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | Best Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | |
| Chris O'Neill | Next Fall | Best Actor / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2012 | |
| KeiLyn Jones | Yellowman | Best Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2012 | |
| Matt Mitchell | The Liar | Best Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2012 | |
| Ryan Bechard | Macbeth | Best Actor / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2012 | Y |
| Ali Thibodeau | Spring Awakening | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Debra Wagoner | Always¿Patsy Cline | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Desiree Roots Centeio | Dessa Rose | Best Actress / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | |
| Jacquie O'Connor | Musical of Musicals | Best Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2012 | |
| Stacey Cabaj | My Fair Lady | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | Y |
| Irene Ziegler | Kimberly Akimbo | Best Actress / Play | Cadence | 2012 | |
| Katrinah Carol Lewis | You Don't Know Me | Best Actress / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | |
| Laine Satterfield | Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | Best Actress / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | |
| Melissa Johnston Price | August: Osage County | Best Actress / Play | Cadence | 2012 | Y |
| Zoe Speas | Macbeth | Best Actress / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2012 | |
| Leslie Owens-Harrington | My Fair Lady | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Maggie Marlin | Rocky Horror Show | Best Choreography | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | Y |
| Starrene Foster | Spring Awakening | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Bruce Miller | My Fair Lady | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Chase Kniffen | Seussical | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Chase Kniffen | Spring Awakening | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | Y |
| Jase Smith | Rocky Horror Show | Best Direction / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | |
| Steve Perigard | A Year with Frog & Toad | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Anna Johnson | Kimberly Akimbo | Best Direction / Play | Cadence | 2012 | |
| Jan Powell | Macbeth | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2012 | Y |
| Keri Wormald | August: Osage County | Best Direction / Play | Cadence | 2012 | |
| Steve Perigard | Scorched Earth | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| God of Carnage | God of Carnage | Best Ensemble Acting | Virginia Rep | 2012 | Y |
| Musical of Musicals | Musical of Musicals | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Triangle Players | 2012 | |
| Picasso at the Lapin Agile | Picasso at the Lapin Agile | Best Ensemble Acting | Sycamore Rouge | 2012 | |
| Stupid Kids | Stupid Kids | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Triangle Players | 2012 | |
| The Liar | The Liar | Best Ensemble Acting | Henley Street | 2012 | |
| Dessa Rose | Dessa Rose | Best Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | |
| Musical of Musicals | Musical of Musicals | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2012 | |
| My Fair Lady | My Fair Lady | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Rocky Horror Show | Rocky Horror Show | Best Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | |
| Spring Awakening | Spring Awakening | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | Y |
| Ben Houghton | My Fair Lady | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2012 | Y |
| Kim Fox | Musical of Musicals | Best Musical Direction | Richmond Triangle Players | 2012 | |
| Leilani Giles | Rocky Horror Show | Best Musical Direction | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | |
| Paul Deiss | A Year with Frog & Toad | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Sandy Dacus | Spring Awakening | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| August: Osage County | August: Osage County | Best Play | Cadence | 2012 | Y |
| Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | Best Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | |
| Kimberly Akimbo | Kimberly Akimbo | Best Play | Cadence | 2012 | |
| The Liar | The Liar | Best Play | Henley Street | 2012 | |
| Tragedy of Macbeth | Tragedy of Macbeth | Best Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2012 | |
| Ben Houghton | My Fair Lady | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Durron Tyre | Dessa Rose | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | |
| Jason Marks | My Fair Lady | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Nick Aliff | Rocky Horror Show | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | Y |
| Richard Chan | Spring Awakening | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Adrian Rieder | In the Next Room | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Cadence | 2012 | |
| Andrew Mitakides | Macbeth | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2012 | |
| Matt Mitchell | Kimberly Akimbo | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Cadence | 2012 | Y |
| Matt Mitchell | Nice People Dancing to Good Country Music | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Richard Koch | Kimberly Akimbo | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Cadence | 2012 | |
| Christie Jackson | Spring Awakening | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | Y |
| Lauren Lienhaas-Cook | My Fair Lady | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Susan Sanford | Spring Awakening | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Susan Sanford | Seussical | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Terri Moore | Always¿Patsy Cline | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Carolyn Meade | August: Osage County | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Cadence | 2012 | |
| Jill Bari Steinberg | Kimberly Akimbo | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Cadence | 2012 | |
| Jody Smith Strickler | August: Osage County | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Cadence | 2012 | |
| Katie McCall | August: Osage County | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Cadence | 2012 | Y |
| Lorri Lindberg | Suddenly, Last Summer | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2012 | |
| Holly Sullivan | Rocky Horror Show | Costume Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | Y |
| Kate Prothemos | Picasso at the Lapin Agile | Costume Design | Sycamore Rouge | 2012 | |
| Maura Lynch Cravey | Blithe | Costume Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2012 | |
| Sue Griffin | My Fair Lady | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Terry Snyder | A Year with Frog & Toad | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Kevin Inouye | Macbeth | Fight Choreography | 2012 | Y | |
| Andrew Bonniwell | Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | Lighting Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | |
| Andrew Bonniwell (w/ Joe Doran) | Lord of the Flies | Lighting Design | Henley Street | 2012 | |
| Joe Doran | The 39 Steps | Lighting Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2012 | Y |
| Joe Doran (w/ Andrew Bonniwell) | Lord of the Flies | Lighting Design | Henley Street | 2012 | |
| Lynne Hartman | Spring Awakening | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Michael Jarrett | Musical of Musicals | Lighting Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2012 | |
| Jeri Cutler-Voltz | Liz Marks | 2012 | Y | ||
| Blue Mountain Christmas | Blue Mountain Christmas | Locally-Developed Work | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Brew | Brew | Locally-Developed Work | Stage B | 2012 | Y |
| Joe Jackson Night & Day | Joe Jackson Night & Day | Locally-Developed Work | Independent | 2012 | |
| Scorched Earth | Scorched Earth | Locally-Developed Work | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Trojans | Trojans | Locally-Developed Work | TheatreLAB | 2012 | |
| Brian Barker | In the Next Room | Set Design | Cadence | 2012 | |
| Brian Barker | Spring Awakening | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Mercedes Schaum | A Year with Frog & Toad | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Phil Hayes | August: Osage County | Set Design | Cadence | 2012 | Y |
| Terrie Powers | Nice People¿ | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2012 | |
| Buddy Bishop | Home Fires | Sound Design | Chamberlayne Actors Theatre | 2012 | |
| James Ricks | Lord of the Flies | Sound Design | Henley Street | 2012 | |
| Jesse Senechal | Kimberly Akimbo | Sound Design | Cadence | 2012 | |
| Paul Deiss | 39 Steps | Sound Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2012 | |
| Paul Deiss | It's A Wonderful Life | Sound Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2012 | Y |
| Rusty Wilson | Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | Sound Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2012 | |
| Tom Width | Stage Magic | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2012 | Y | |
| Duke Lafoon | Next to Normal | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | Y |
| Ian Page | bare: a pop opera | Best Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | |
| Larry Cook | The Music Man | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Matt Beyer | La Cage aux Folles | Best Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | |
| Scott Wichmann | The Producers | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Billy Christopher Maupin | A Bright New Boise | Best Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2013 | |
| David Bridgewater | Red | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| David Janosik | King John | Best Actor / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2013 | |
| Deejay Gray | Riding the Bull | Best Actor / Play | TheatreLAB | 2013 | |
| Joe Pabst | Faith Healer | Best Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2013 | Y |
| Amanda Johnson | The Music Man | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Andrea Rivette | Next to Normal | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | Y |
| Debra Wagoner | Magic Flute | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Grey Garrett | I Love a Piano | Best Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2013 | |
| Morgan Meadows | bare: a pop opera | Best Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | |
| Eva DeVirgilis | Search/Signs | Best Actress / Play | Henley Street | 2013 | |
| Jill Bari Steinberg | The Beauty Queen of Lenane | Best Actress / Play | Henley Street | 2013 | |
| Maggie Bavalack | Riding the Bull | Best Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2013 | Y |
| Mary Best Bova | The Beauty Queen of Lenane | Best Actress / Play | Henley Street | 2013 | |
| Terry Menefee Gau | Glass Menagerie | Best Actress / Play | Sycamore Rouge | 2013 | |
| Leslie Owens-Harrington | The Music Man | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Nicole Oberleitner | La Cage aux Folles | Best Choreography | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | |
| Patti D'Beck | The Producers | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2013 | Y |
| Starrene Foster | Pop! | Best Choreography | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2013 | |
| Chase Kniffen | Next to Normal | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Joe Pabst | La Cage aux Folles | Best Direction / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | |
| John Moon | The Music Man | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Justin Amellio | bare: a pop opera | Best Direction / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | Y |
| Patti D'Beck | The Producers | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Anna Johnson | Sons of the Prophet | Best Direction / Play | Cadence | 2013 | |
| Bo Wilson | Beauty Queen of Lenane | Best Direction / Play | Henley Street | 2013 | |
| James Ricks | Julius Caesar | Best Direction / Play | Henley Street | 2013 | Y |
| Jan Powell | King John | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2013 | |
| Steve Perigard | A Comedy of Errors | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2013 | |
| Gidion's Knot | Gidion's Knot | Best Ensemble Acting | Carol Piersol / HATTheatre | 2013 | Y |
| Steel Magnolias | Steel Magnolias | Best Ensemble Acting | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| The Beauty Queen of Lenane | The Beauty Queen of Lenane | Best Ensemble Acting | Henley Street | 2013 | |
| The Glass Menagerie | The Glass Menagerie | Best Ensemble Acting | Sycamore Rouge | 2013 | Y |
| The Pillowman | The Pillowman | Best Ensemble Acting | Cadence | 2013 | |
| bare: a pop opera | bare: a pop opera | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | Y |
| La Cage aux Folles | La Cage aux Folles | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | |
| Next to Normal | Next to Normal | Best Musical | Cadence | 2013 | |
| The Music Man | The Music Man | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| The Producers | The Producers | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Andrew Hamm | A Child's Xmas in Wales | Best Musical Direction | Richmond Shakespeare | 2013 | |
| Douglas Minerd | The Producers | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Kim Fox | bare: a pop opera | Best Musical Direction | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | |
| Kim Fox | Next to Normal | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2013 | Y |
| Paul Deiss | I Love a Piano | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2013 | |
| A Comedy of Errors | A Comedy of Errors | Best Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2013 | Y |
| Death of a Salesman | Death of a Salesman | Best Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2013 | |
| Julius Caesar | Henley Street | Best Play | Henley Street | 2013 | |
| Sons of the Prophet | Sons of the Prophet | Best Play | Cadence | 2013 | |
| The Beauty Queen of Lenane | The Beauty Queen of Lenane | Best Play | Henley Street | 2013 | |
| Ian Stearns | Pop! | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2013 | |
| Jody Ashworth | The Producers | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | Y |
| John Mincks | Next to Normal | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Michael Hawke | The Producers | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Terence Sullivan | Next to Normal | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Adrian Rieder | Death of a Salesman | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2013 | |
| D J Cummings | Sons of the Prophet | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Cadence | 2013 | |
| David Janeski | The Pillowman | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Cadence | 2013 | |
| Jeffrey Schmidt | Julius Caesar | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Henley Street | 2013 | |
| Nick Aliff | Any Given Monday | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2013 | Y |
| Audra Honaker | Pop! | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2013 | |
| Christie Jackson | Next to Normal | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Kelsey Cordrey | bare: a pop opera | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | Y |
| Liz Blake White | A Child's Xmas in Wales | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Richmond Shakespeare | 2013 | |
| Nicole Oberleitner | La Cage aux Folles | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | |
| Maggie Roop | Hay Fever | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| McLean Jesse | Glass Menagerie | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Sycamore Rouge | 2013 | |
| Melissa Johnston Price | Sons of the Prophet | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Cadence | 2013 | |
| Molly Hood | A Comedy of Errors | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2013 | Y |
| Stacie Reardon Hall | The Pride | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | |
| Alex Valentin | bare: a pop opera | Costume Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | |
| D. Mark Souza | La Cage aux Folles | Costume Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | |
| Margarette Joyner | Julius Caesar | Costume Design | Henley Street | 2013 | |
| Sarah Grady | The Music Man | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Sue Griffin | Hound of the Baskervilles | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Thomas Hammond | Whoop-Dee-Do | Costume Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | Y |
| Andrew Bonniwell | Julius Caesar | Lighting Design | Henley Street | 2013 | |
| Jacob Sailer | Red | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| K. Jenna Ferree | Next to Normal | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2013 | Y |
| Lynne Hartman | Red | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Lynne Hartman | The Music Man | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| Robert Perry | Bright New Boise | Lighting Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2013 | |
| Tom McGranahan | Liz Marks | 2013 | Y | ||
| David Allan Ballas | Busy World is Hushed | Set Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2013 | |
| Mercedes Schaum | Hay Fever | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2013 | Y |
| Tennessee Dixon | Julius Caesar | Set Design | Henley Street | 2013 | |
| Todd Schall-Vess | King John | Set Design | Richmond Shakespeare | 2013 | |
| Alecia Shulz (w/ Brittany Simmons) | King John | Sound Design | Richmond Shakespeare | 2013 | |
| Brittany Simmons (w/ Alecia Shulz) | King John | Sound Design | Richmond Shakespeare | 2013 | |
| Derek Dumais | Hound of the Baskervilles | Sound Design | Virginia Rep | 2013 | |
| James Ricks | Julius Caesar | Sound Design | Henley Street | 2013 | |
| James Ricks | Search for Signs | Sound Design | Henley Street | 2013 | |
| Joey Luck | A Bright New Boise | Sound Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2013 | Y |
| Chris Hester | Cabaret | Best Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2014 | |
| David Benoit | Fiddler on the Roof | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Jason Marks | Shrek the Musical | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Jerold Solomon | The Color Purple | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Josh Marin | The Color Purple | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | Y |
| Ronnie Brown | Shrek the Musical | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Aaron Orensky | Joshua Plant | Best Actor / Play | Chamberlayne Actors Theatre | 2014 | |
| Alexander Sapp | Grace | Best Actor / Play | TheatreLAB | 2014 | |
| Jeffrey Cole | Wittenberg | Best Actor / Play | Henley Street/Richmond Shakes | 2014 | |
| Joseph Carlson | A Streetcar Named Desire | Best Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2014 | |
| Scott Wichmann | Say Goodnight Gracie | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2014 | Y |
| Aly Wepplo | Shrek the Musical | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Christie Jackson | The Drowsy Chaperone | Best Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | |
| Felicia Curry | The Color Purple | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | Y |
| Grey Garrett | Beyond the Rainbow | Best Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | |
| Nicole Oberleitner | Cabaret | Best Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2014 | |
| Catherine Shaffner | night Mother | Best Actress / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2014 | Y |
| Dawn A. Westbrook | Good People | Best Actress / Play | Cadence | 2014 | |
| Eva DeVirgilis | Hypocrites & Strippers | Best Actress / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2014 | |
| Katrinah Carol Lewis | Death & the Maiden | Best Actress / Play | Henley Street/Richmond Shakes | 2014 | |
| McLean Jesse | Clybourne Park | Best Actress / Play | Cadence | 2014 | |
| Dennis Clark | The Drowsy Chaperone | Best Choreography | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | |
| Karen Getz | Fiddler on the Roof | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Leslie Owens-Harrington | The Color Purple | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2014 | Y |
| Penny Ayn Maas | Cabaret | Best Choreography | Richmond Triangle Players | 2014 | |
| Robin Arthur | Shrek the Musical | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Chase Kniffen | The Color Purple | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | Y |
| Penny Ayn Maas | Cabaret | Best Direction / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2014 | |
| Richard Parison | Fiddler on the Roof | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Robin Arthur | Shrek the Musical | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Tom Width | The Drowsy Chaperone | Best Direction / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | |
| Anna Johnson | Detroit | Best Direction / Play | Cadence | 2014 | |
| Anna Johnson | Good People | Best Direction / Play | Cadence | 2014 | |
| David Emerson Toney | night mother | Best Direction / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2014 | |
| Keri Wormald | Clybourne Park | Best Direction / Play | Cadence | 2014 | Y |
| Kerry McGee | The Elaborate Entrance Of Chad Deity | Best Direction / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2014 | |
| Clybourne Park | Clybourne Park | Best Ensemble Acting | Cadence | 2014 | |
| Detroit | Detroit | Best Ensemble Acting | Cadence | 2014 | |
| Grace | Grace | Best Ensemble Acting | TheatreLAB | 2014 | |
| Quality of Life | Quality of Life | Best Ensemble Acting | HATTheatre | 2014 | |
| The Elaborate Entrance Of Chad Deity | The Elaborate Entrance Of Chad Deity | Best Ensemble Acting | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2014 | Y |
| Cabaret | Cabaret | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2014 | |
| Fiddler on the Roof | Fiddler on the Roof | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Shrek The Musical | Shrek The Musical | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| The Color Purple | The Color Purple | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | Y |
| The Drowsy Chaperone | The Drowsy Chaperone | Best Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | |
| Anthony Smith | Fiddler of the Roof | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Ben Miller | The Color Purple | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Ben Miller | The Wild Party | Best Musical Direction | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2014 | |
| Kim Fox | Cabaret | Best Musical Direction | Richmond Triangle Players | 2014 | |
| Paul Deiss | The Drowsy Chaperone | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | Y |
| Clybourne Park | Clybourne Park | Best Play | Cadence | 2014 | Y |
| Good People | Good People | Best Play | Cadence | 2014 | |
| Joshua Plant | Joshua Plant | Best Play | Chamberlayne Actors Theatre | 2014 | |
| Quality of Life | Quality of Life | Best Play | HATTheatre | 2014 | |
| The Elaborate Entrance Of Chad Deity | The Elaborate Entrance Of Chad Deity | Best Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2014 | |
| Doug Schneider | Cabaret | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2014 | Y |
| Josh Marin | The Wild Party | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2014 | |
| Matt Shofner | The Drowsy Chaperone | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | |
| Scott Wichmann | Olympus on my Mind | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Steve King | The Drowsy Chaperone | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | |
| Alexander Sapp | Richard III | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Henley Street/Richmond Shakes | 2014 | Y |
| Alexander Sapp | Tartuffe | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Andrew Firda | Clybourne Park | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Cadence | 2014 | |
| Mauricio Marces | The Elaborate Entrance Of Chad Deity | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2014 | Y |
| Stephen Ryan | The Importance of Being Earnest | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Henley St/RichShakes/RTP | 2014 | |
| Carolyn Meade | The Wild Party | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2014 | |
| Carolyn Minor-Daughtry | The Color Purple | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Desiree Roots Centeio | The Color Purple | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Jeanie Rule | Cabaret | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2014 | Y |
| Nicole Oberleitner | The Drowsy Chaperone | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | |
| Debra Wagoner | Tartuffe | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Jacquie O'Connor | Good People | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Cadence | 2014 | Y |
| Jennifer Frank | The Dixie Swim Club | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | |
| Melissa Johnston Price | Other Desert Cities | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Raven Wilkes | Midsummer Nights Dream | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Henley Street/Richmond Shakes | 2014 | |
| Elizabeth Weiss Hopper | Shrek the Musical | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2014 | Y |
| Maura Lynch Cravey | The Drowsy Chaperone | Costume Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | |
| Sue Griffin | Fiddler on the Roof | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Sue Griffin | Tartuffe | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Sue Griffin | The Color Purple | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| James Long | The Elaborate Entrance Of Chad Deity | Fight Choreography | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2014 | Y |
| Geno Brantley | The Elaborate Entrance Of Chad Deity | Lighting Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2014 | Y |
| Joe Doran | The Color Purple | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Joe Doran | The Drowsy Chaperone | Lighting Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | |
| Lynne Hartman | Other Desert Cities | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Robert Perry | Fiddler on the Roof | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Acts of Faith Festival | Liz Marks | 2014 | Y | ||
| Ally Dods | Fiddler on the Roof | Promising Newcomer | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Brad Frazier | Tartuffe | Promising Newcomer | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Diego Salinas | Joshua Plant | Promising Newcomer | Chamberlayne Actors Theatre | 2014 | Y |
| Grace Mincks | Beyond the Rainbow | Promising Newcomer | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | Y |
| Isabella Cipolina | Miracle Worker | Promising Newcomer | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | |
| Ben Burke | Other Desert Cities | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2014 | Y |
| Frank Foster | Cabaret | Set Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2014 | |
| Ron Keller | The Color Purple | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Tennessee Dixon | Death & the Maiden | Set Design | Henley Street/Richmond Shakes | 2014 | |
| Tom Width | The Drowsy Chaperone | Set Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2014 | |
| Andrew Craig | Death & the Maiden | Sound Design | Henley Street/Richmond Shakes | 2014 | |
| Chase Kniffen | Say Goodnight Gracie | Sound Design | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Derek Dumais | The Color Purple | Sound Design | Virginia Rep | 2014 | |
| Joey Luck | Cabaret | Sound Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2014 | Y |
| Joey Luck | The Elaborate Entrance Of Chad Deity | Sound Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2014 | |
| Branch Fields | South Pacific | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| David Janeski | You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Denver Crawford | Boy in the Bathroom | Best Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2015 | |
| Landon Nagel | They're Playing Our Song | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Matt Shofner | Hedwig and the Angry Inch | Best Actor / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2015 | Y |
| Andrew Firda | Angels in America | Best Actor / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2015 | |
| Jerold Solomon | The Whipping Man | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2015 | Y |
| Marquis Hazelwood | When Last We Flew | Best Actor / Play | TheatreLAB | 2015 | |
| Nick Aliff | Sam & Carol | Best Actor / Play | Quill Theatre | 2015 | |
| Rafael Untalan | Equivocation | Best Actor / Play | Quill/VA Rep | 2015 | |
| Aly Wepplo | They're Playing Our Song | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Brittany Simmons | Carrie the Musical | Best Actress / Musical | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | |
| Cathy Shaffner | Boy in the Bathroom | Best Actress / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2015 | |
| Desiree Roots Centeio | Caroline, or Change | Best Actress / Musical | Cadence | 2015 | Y |
| Stacey Cabaj | South Pacific | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Eva DeVirgilis | Sam & Carol | Best Actress / Play | Quill Theatre | 2015 | |
| Jacqueline Jones | The Lyons | Best Actress / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | |
| McLean Jesse | The Human Terrain | Best Actress / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | Y |
| Melissa Johnston Price | Lion in Winter | Best Actress / Play | Quill Theatre | 2015 | |
| Molly Hood | Hamlet | Best Actress / Play | Quill Theatre | 2015 | |
| Brad Willcuts | South Pacific | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2015 | Y |
| Emily Poff | Carrie the Musical | Best Choreography | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | |
| Jan Guarino | They're Playing Our Song | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Patti D'Beck | Mame | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Billy Christopher Maupin | Carrie the Musical | Best Direction / Musical | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | Y |
| Chase Kniffen | South Pacific | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Maggie Roop | Hedwig and the Angry Inch | Best Direction / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2015 | |
| Patti D'Beck | Mame | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Tom Width | Two Bits: The Barbershop Musical | Best Direction / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2015 | |
| Bo Wilson | Angels in America | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2015 | |
| Carol Piersol | The Human Terrain | Best Direction / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | |
| Debra Clinton | The Whipping Man | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Jan Powell | Equivocation | Best Direction / Play | Quill/VA Rep | 2015 | Y |
| Jan Powell | Hamlet | Best Direction / Play | Quill Theatre | 2015 | |
| Angels in America | Angels in America | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Triangle Players | 2015 | |
| Cock | Cock | Best Ensemble Acting | TheatreLAB | 2015 | |
| The Altruists | The Altruists | Best Ensemble Acting | TheatreLAB | 2015 | Y |
| The Human Terrain | The Human Terrain | Best Ensemble Acting | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | |
| The Whipping Man | The Whipping Man | Best Ensemble Acting | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Caroline, or Change | Caroline, or Change | Best Musical | Cadence | 2015 | Y |
| Carrie the Musical | Carrie the Musical | Best Musical | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | |
| Hedwig and the Angry Inch | Hedwig and the Angry Inch | Best Musical | TheatreLAB | 2015 | |
| South Pacific | South Pacific | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Two Bits: The Barbershop Musical | Two Bits: The Barbershop Musical | Best Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2015 | |
| Anthony Smith | Carrie the Musical | Best Musical Direction | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | |
| Drew Perkins | A Lie of the Mind | Best Musical Direction | Cadence | 2015 | |
| Hedwig and the Angry Inch | Hedwig and the Angry Inch | Best Musical Direction | TheatreLAB | 2015 | |
| Paul Deiss | Two Bits: The Barbershop Musical | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2015 | |
| Ryan Corbitt | Caroline, or Change | Best Musical Direction | Cadence | 2015 | Y |
| Equivocation | Equivocation | Best Play | Quill/VA Rep | 2015 | |
| Hamlet | Hamlet | Best Play | Quill Theatre | 2015 | |
| The Human Terrain | The Human Terrain | Best Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | Y |
| The Lyons | The Lyons | Best Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | |
| The Whipping Man | The Whipping Man | Best Play | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Audra Honaker | Mame | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Bianca Bryan | Caroline, or Change | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Cadence | 2015 | |
| Bianca Bryan | Hedwig and the Angry Inch | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2015 | |
| Brandon McKinney | Caroline, or Change | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Cadence | 2015 | Y |
| Brian Baez | Pageant | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2015 | |
| Durron Tyre | You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Grace Mincks | Carrie the Musical | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | Y |
| James Stover | South Pacific | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Kirk Morton | We Three Lizas | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2015 | |
| Matt Zimmerman | South Pacific | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Tyandria Ford Jackson | Caroline, or Change | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Cadence | 2015 | |
| Deejay Gray | The Whale | Best Supporting Actor / Play | HATTheatre | 2015 | |
| Jeff Clevenger | Hamlet | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Quill Theatre | 2015 | Y |
| Joe Pabst | Equivocation | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Quill/VA Rep | 2015 | |
| Max Eddy | The Whipping Man | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Taamu Wuya | The Whipping Man | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Jessi Johnson | Psycho Beach Party | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2015 | |
| Maggie Roop | Last of the Red Hot Lovers | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Raven Lorraine | When Last We Flew | Best Supporting Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2015 | |
| Sara Heifetz | The Human Terrain | Best Supporting Actress / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | Y |
| Zoe Speas | Equivocation | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Quill/VA Rep | 2015 | |
| Anna Bialkowski | Hamlet | Costume Design | Quill Theatre | 2015 | |
| D. Mark Souza | 5 Lesbians Eating a Quiche | Costume Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2015 | |
| Elizabeth Weiss Hopper | Equivocation | Costume Design | Quill/VA Rep | 2015 | |
| Sue Griffin | Mame | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2015 | Y |
| Sue Griffin | South Pacific | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| BJ Wilkinson | Equivocation | Lighting Design | Quill/VA Rep | 2015 | |
| BJ Wilkinson | The Whipping Man | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2015 | Y |
| Lynn Hartman | Mame | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Michael Jarett | Angels in America | Lighting Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2015 | |
| Robby Williams | Boy in the Bathroom | Lighting Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2015 | |
| Bob Albertia | Liz Marks | 2015 | Y | ||
| deVeaux Riddick & Robert Watkins | Liz Marks | 2015 | Y | ||
| Denver Crawford | The Aliens | Promising Newcomer | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2015 | Y |
| Joseph Nelson | Oblivion | Promising Newcomer | TheatreLAB | 2015 | |
| Saleh Ismael | The Human Terrain | Promising Newcomer | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | |
| Tyandria Ford Jackson | Caroline, or Change | Promising Newcomer | Cadence | 2015 | |
| Zoe Cotzias | Oblivion | Promising Newcomer | TheatreLAB | 2015 | |
| Christopher Acebo | Equivocation | Set Design | Quill/VA Rep | 2015 | |
| Edwin Slipek | Wait Until Dark | Set Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2015 | |
| Kat Conley | The Whipping Man | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2015 | Y |
| Ron Keller | Mame | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2015 | |
| Tennessee Dixon | Boy in the Bathroom | Set Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2015 | |
| Carlos Collazo | The Human Terrain | Sound Design | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | |
| Joey Luck | Carrie the Musical | Sound Design | 5th Wall Theatre | 2015 | |
| Joey Luck | Hedwig and the Angry Inch | Sound Design | TheatreLAB | 2015 | |
| Joey Luck | Psycho Beach Party | Sound Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2015 | Y |
| Joey Luck | The Aliens | Sound Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2015 | |
| Alexander Sapp | Croaker: The Frog Prince Musical | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Chris Hester | The Boy From Oz | Best Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2016 | Y |
| Denver Crawford | Green Day's American Idiot | Best Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2016 | |
| Ian Page | Little Shop of Horrors | Best Actor / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Jerold Solomon | Dreamgirls | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Alan Sader | American Buffalo | Best Actor / Play | Quill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Alexander Sapp | Summer and Smoke | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Jerold Solomon | The Mountaintop | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Joe Inscoe | King Lear | Best Actor / Play | Quill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Matthew Radford Davies | The Merchant of Venice | Best Actor / Play | Quill Theatre | 2016 | Y |
| Scott Wichmann | Peter and the Starcatcher | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Audra Honaker | Little Shop of Horrors | Best Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Desiree Roots | Dreamgirls | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Jenna Kraynak | Seven Brides for Seven Brothers | Best Actress / Musical | Nu Puppis | 2016 | |
| Katrinah Carol Lewis | Lady Day at Emerson's Bar and Grill | Best Actress / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2016 | Y |
| Robyn O'Neill | Gypsy | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Irene Ziegler | 4000 Miles | Best Actress / Play | Cadence | 2016 | |
| Katrinah Carol Lewis | The Mountaintop | Best Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Kelsey Cordrey | Bad Jews | Best Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2016 | |
| Kimberly Jones Clark | Christmas on the Rocks | Best Actress / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2016 | |
| Maggie Roop | Venus in Fur | Best Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2016 | Y |
| Debra Clinton | Croaker: The Frog Prince Musical | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Justin Amellio | The Boy from Oz | Best Choreography | Richmond Triangle Players | 2016 | |
| Kate Belleman | Green Day's American Idiot | Best Choreography | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2016 | Y |
| Leslie Owens-Harrington | Dreamgirls | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Scott Putman | Equus | Best Choreography | Cadence | 2016 | |
| Adam Ferguson, | Green Day's American Idiot | Best Direction / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2016 | |
| Chase Kniffen | Dreamgirls | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Debra Clinton, | Croaker: The Frog Prince Musical | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Deejay Gray | Lady Day at Emerson's Bar and Grill | Best Direction / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2016 | |
| Tom Width | Little Shop of Horrors | Best Direction / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Anna Johnson | Equus | Best Direction / Play | Cadence | 2016 | |
| Daniel Moore | American Buffalo | Best Direction / Play | Quill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Jon Kretzu | Stupid Fucking Bird | Best Direction / Play | Quill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Laine Satterfield | The Mountaintop | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2016 | Y |
| Matt Shofner | Venus in Fur | Best Direction / Play | TheatreLAB | 2016 | |
| Nathaniel Shaw | Peter and the Starcatcher | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| American Buffalo | Best Ensemble Acting | Quill Theatre | 2016 | ||
| Bad Jews | Best Ensemble Acting | TheatreLAB | 2016 | Y | |
| Brighton Beach Memoirs | Best Ensemble Acting | Virginia Rep | 2016 | ||
| Green Day's American Idiot | Best Ensemble Acting | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2016 | ||
| Mr. Burns: A Post-Electric Play | Best Ensemble Acting | TheatreLAB | 2016 | ||
| Stupid Fucking Bird | Best Ensemble Acting | Quill Theatre | 2016 | ||
| Croaker: The Frog Prince Musical | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2016 | ||
| Dreamgirls | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2016 | Y | |
| Green Day's American Idiot | Best Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2016 | ||
| Little Shop of Horrors | Best Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2016 | ||
| The Boy From Oz | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2016 | ||
| John Winn | Dreamgirls | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2016 | Y |
| Jose Simbulan | Gypsy | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Kim Fox | The Boy From Oz | Best Musical Direction | Richmond Triangle Players | 2016 | |
| Matt Koon | Green Day's American Idiot | Best Musical Direction | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2016 | |
| Travis West | Little Shop of Horrors | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2016 | |
| 4000 Miles | Best Play | Cadence | 2016 | ||
| American Buffalo | Best Play | Quill Theatre | 2016 | ||
| Peter and the Starcatcher | Best Play | Virginia Rep | 2016 | ||
| Stupid Fucking Bird | Best Play | Quill Theatre | 2016 | ||
| The Mountaintop | Best Play | Virginia Rep | 2016 | ||
| Venus in Fur | Best Play | TheatreLAB | 2016 | Y | |
| Adam Mincks | Little Shop of Horrors | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Billy Dye | Dreamgirls | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| D. Jerome Wells | Dreamgirls | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2016 | Y |
| Durron Tyre | Dreamgirls | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Mahlan Raoufi | Seven Brides for Seven Brothers | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Nu Puppis | 2016 | |
| Alan Sader | The Lazarus Syndrome | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2016 | Y |
| Jeff Clevenger | Stupid Fucking Bird | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Quill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Larry Cook | Equus | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Cadence | 2016 | |
| Robert Throckmorton | Peter and the Starcatcher | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Trevor Craft | Brighton Beach Memoirs | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Anna Hogan | The Boy From Oz | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2016 | |
| Felicia Curry | Dreamgirls | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Grey Garrett | The Boy From Oz | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2016 | Y |
| Jeannie Rule | The Boy From Oz | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2016 | |
| Kathy Halenda | Croaker: The Frog Prince Musical | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Audra Honaker | Stupid Fucking Bird | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Quill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Catherine Carol Walker | Bad Jews | Best Supporting Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2016 | |
| Jessi Johnson | Mr. Burns: A Post-Electric Play | Best Supporting Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2016 | Y |
| Margarette Joyner | for colored girls who have considered suicide / when the rainbow is enuf | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Heritage | 2016 | |
| Megan Graves | Peter and the Starcatcher | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Jeanne Nugent | Croaker: The Frog Prince Musical | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Jeanne Nugent | Peter and the Starcatcher | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Mark Souza | The Boy from Oz | Costume Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2016 | |
| Sarah Grady | Dreamgirls | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2016 | Y |
| Sue Griffin | Gypsy | Costume Design | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| BJ Wilkinson | Summer and Smoke | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Joe Doran | Dreamgirls | Lighting Design | Virginia Rep | 2016 | Y |
| Joe Doran | Little Shop of Horrors | Lighting Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Joe Doran | The Little Lion | Lighting Design | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Michael Jarrett | The Boy from Oz | Lighting Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2016 | |
| Frances Wessells | Liz Marks | 2016 | |||
| Marie Goodman Hunter | Liz Marks | 2016 | |||
| Alex Mayberry | Sadie's Last Painting | Outstanding Original Work | Free Jambalaya | 2016 | |
| Debra Clinton | Croaker: The Frog Prince Musical | Outstanding Original Work | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Irene Ziegler | The Little Lion | Outstanding Original Work | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Jason Marks | Croaker: The Frog Prince Musical | Outstanding Original Work | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Margarette Joyner | Sweet Chocolate and the Seven Christians | Outstanding Original Work | Heritage | 2016 | |
| Adam Valentine | Maple and Vine | Promising Newcomer | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2016 | |
| Ben Wilson | Green Day's American Idiot | Promising Newcomer | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2016 | |
| Emma Grace Bailey | Creating Claire | Promising Newcomer | HATTheatre | 2016 | |
| Killian Winn | King Lear | Promising Newcomer | Quill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Tyler Stevens | Brighton Beach Memoirs | Promising Newcomer | Virginia Rep | 2016 | Y |
| Craig Napoliello | Peter and the Starcatcher | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Rich Mason | Summer and Smoke | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Ron Keller | Dreamgirls | Set Design | Virginia Rep | 2016 | Y |
| Tennessee Dixon | Stupid Fucking Bird | Set Design | Quill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Vinnie Gonzalez | American Buffalo | Set Design | Quill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Derek Dumais | Dreamgirls | Sound Design | Virginia Rep | 2016 | |
| Jesse Senechel | The Mountaintop | Sound Design | Virginia Rep | 2016 | Y |
| Joey Luck | The Boy from Oz | Sound Design | Richmond Triangle Players | 2016 | |
| Kelsey Cordrey | American Buffalo | Sound Design | Quill Theatre | 2016 | |
| Tadd Burrell | Green Day's American Idiot | Sound Design | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2016 | |
| Alexander Sapp | The Toxic Avenger | Best Actor / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2017 | Y |
| JJ Caruncho | In the Heights | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Josh Marin | Violet | Best Actor / Musical | Cadence | 2017 | |
| Matt Polson | Violet | Best Actor / Musical | Cadence | 2017 | |
| Scott Wichmann | 1776 | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Alex Johnson | Love’s Labour’s Lost | Best Actor / Play | Quill Theatre | 2017 | |
| Dean Knight | Dancing Lessons | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2017 | Y |
| Duke Lafoon | Rabbit Hole | Best Actor / Play | Cadence | 2017 | |
| Jeremy V. Morris | The Top of Bravery | Best Actor / Play | Quill/AART | 2017 | Y |
| Nicklas Aliff | The End of War | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Arielle Jacobs | In the Heights | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Carmen Wiley | Heathers: The Musical | Best Actress / Musical | Firehouse/TheatreLab | 2017 | |
| Christie Jackson | Violet | Best Actress / Musical | Cadence | 2017 | |
| Debra Wagoner | The Toxic Avenger | Best Actress / Musical | 5th Wall Theatre | 2017 | Y |
| Georgia Rogers Farmer | It Shoulda Been You | Best Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2017 | |
| Bianca Bryan | Grounded | Best Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2017 | |
| Boomie Pedersen | Mother Courage and Her Children | Best Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2017 | |
| Dawn Westbrook | Grand Concourse | Best Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2017 | Y |
| Jessie Kraemer | Dry Land | Best Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2017 | |
| Katrinah Carol Lewis | Twilight: Los Angeles, 1992 | Best Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2017 | |
| Aza Raine | Heathers: The Musical | Best Choreography | Firehouse/TheatreLab | 2017 | |
| Dr. E. Gaynell Sherrod | The Top of Bravery | Best Choreography | Quill/AART | 2017 | |
| Emily Dandridge | The Toxic Avenger | Best Choreography | 5th Wall Theatre | 2017 | |
| Karla Garcia | In the Heights | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2017 | Y |
| Nicole Oberleitner | A Christmas Story: The Musical | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Chase Kniffen | Violet | Best Direction / Musical | Cadence | 2017 | |
| Debra Clinton | 1776 | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Jon Kretzu | It Shoulda Been You | Best Direction / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2017 | |
| Keith Fitzgerald | The Toxic Avenger | Best Direction / Musical | 5th Wall Theatre | 2017 | |
| Nathaniel Shaw | In the Heights | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Anna Johnson | Rabbit Hole | Best Direction / Play | Cadence | 2017 | |
| Chelsea Burke | Grand Concourse | Best Direction / Play | TheatreLAB | 2017 | Y |
| James Ricks | Love’s Labour’s Lost | Best Direction / Play | Quill Theatre | 2017 | |
| Nathaniel Shaw | The End of War | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Rusty Wilson | John | Best Direction / Play | Cadence | 2017 | Y |
| Grand Concourse | Best Ensemble Acting | TheatreLAB | 2017 | ||
| Heathers: The Musical | Best Ensemble Acting | Firehouse/TheatreLab | 2017 | ||
| It Shoulda Been You | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Triangle Players | 2017 | ||
| The Top of Bravery | Best Ensemble Acting | Quill/AART | 2017 | ||
| The Toxic Avenger | Best Ensemble Acting | 5th Wall Theatre | 2017 | Y | |
| 1776 | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | ||
| In the Heights | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | Y | |
| It Shoulda Been You | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2017 | ||
| The Toxic Avenger | Best Musical | 5th Wall Theatre | 2017 | ||
| Violet | Best Musical | Cadence | 2017 | ||
| Ben Miller | A Christmas Story: The Musical | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Ben Miller | In the Heights | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2017 | Y |
| Kim Fox | It Shoulda Been You | Best Musical Direction | Richmond Triangle Players | 2017 | |
| Sandy Dacus | 1776 | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Starlet Knight | The Toxic Avenger | Best Musical Direction | 5th Wall Theatre | 2017 | |
| Bo Wilson | The Boatwright | Best Original Work | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2017 | |
| David Robbins | The End of War | Best Original Work | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| James Ricks | UBU 84 | Best Original Work | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2017 | |
| Jeremy V. Morris | The Top of Bravery | Best Original Work | Quill/AART | 2017 | Y |
| Grand Concourse | Best Play | TheatreLAB | 2017 | ||
| John | Best Play | Cadence | 2017 | ||
| Love’s Labour’s Lost | Best Play | Quill Theatre | 2017 | ||
| Rabbit Hole | Best Play | Cadence | 2017 | ||
| The End of War | Best Play | Virginia Rep | 2017 | ||
| Alexander Sapp | 1776 | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | Y |
| James Schoppe | In the Heights | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Josh Marin | In the Heights | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Matt Shofner | Assassins | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Quill Theatre | 2017 | |
| William Anderson | The Toxic Avenger | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | 5th Wall Theatre | 2017 | |
| Joshua Gutierrez | Grand Concourse | Best Supporting Actor / Play | TheatreLAB | 2017 | |
| Kenneth Putnam | Cash on Delivery | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2017 | |
| Luke Schares | Love’s Labour’s Lost | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Quill Theatre | 2017 | |
| Trevor Craft | Da | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Tyler Stevens | Rabbit Hole | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Cadence | 2017 | Y |
| Bianca Bryan | Assassins | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Quill Theatre | 2017 | |
| Christie Jackson | Heathers: The Musical | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Firehouse/TheatreLab | 2017 | |
| Louise Ricks | It Shoulda Been You | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2017 | |
| Susan Sanford | It Shoulda Been You | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2017 | Y |
| Yvonne Strumecki | In the Heights | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Aiden Orr | Rapture, Blister, Burn | Best Supporting Actress / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2017 | |
| Audra Honaker | Bill W. and Dr. Bob | Best Supporting Actress / Play | HATTheatre | 2017 | |
| Grey Garrett | Rabbit Hole | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Cadence | 2017 | Y |
| Jean H. Miller | John | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Cadence | 2017 | |
| Paige Larson | The End of War | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Ruth Hedberg | Heathers: The Musical | Costume Design / Musical | Firehouse/TheatreLab | 2017 | |
| Sarah Grady | In the Heights | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Sheila Russ | The Toxic Avenger | Costume Design / Musical | 5th Wall Theatre | 2017 | |
| Sue Griffin | 1776 | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | Y |
| Terry Snyder | Disney’s Beauty and the Beast | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Cora Delbridge | UBU 84 | Costume Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2017 | |
| Elizabeth Weiss Hopper | The Heir Apparent | Costume Design / Play | Quill Theatre | 2017 | |
| Emily Tappan | Airline Highway | Costume Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Lynn West | Perfect Arrangement | Costume Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2017 | |
| Sue Griffin | The End of War | Costume Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2017 | Y |
| Leslie Cheek, Jr. | Legacy Award | 2017 | Y | ||
| Muriel McAuley (w/ Nancy Kilgore and Pete Kilgore) | Legacy Award | Barksdale Theatre | 2017 | Y | |
| Nancy Kilgore (w/ Pete Kilgore and Muriel McAuley) | Legacy Award | Barksdale Theatre | 2017 | Y | |
| Pete Kilgore (w/ Nancy Kilgore and Muriel McAuley) | Legacy Award | Barksdale Theatre | 2017 | Y | |
| Raymond Hodges | Legacy Award | 2017 | Y | ||
| Gregg Hillmar | Violet | Lighting Design / Musical | Cadence | 2017 | |
| Joe Doran | A Christmas Story: The Musical | Lighting Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Joe Doran | In the Heights | Lighting Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | Y |
| Joe Doran | Musical of Musicals: The Musical | Lighting Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2017 | |
| Michael Jarrett | Heathers: The Musical | Lighting Design / Musical | Firehouse/TheatreLab | 2017 | |
| B.J. Wilkinson | Da | Lighting Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| B.J. Wilkinson | The End of War | Lighting Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2017 | Y |
| Erin Barclay | Grounded | Lighting Design / Play | TheatreLAB | 2017 | |
| Joe Doran | Almost, Maine | Lighting Design / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2017 | |
| Skyler Broughman | Dracula | Lighting Design / Play | Quill Theatre | 2017 | |
| Tennessee Dixon | Projection Design | 2017 | Y | ||
| Aiden Orr | Rapture, Blister, Burn | Promising Newcomer | 5th Wall Theatre | 2017 | |
| Akiel Baldwin | Choir Boy | Promising Newcomer | RTP/Heritage | 2017 | |
| Carmen Wiley | Heathers: The Musical | Promising Newcomer | Firehouse/TheatreLab | 2017 | Y |
| Ellie Duffey | Love’s Labour’s Lost | Promising Newcomer | Quill Theatre | 2017 | |
| Roberto Whitaker | In the Heights | Promising Newcomer | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Anna Louizos | In the Heights | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Brian C. Barker | A Christmas Story: The Musical | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Joel Sherry | Disney’s Beauty and the Beast | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Rich Mason | Violet | Set Design / Musical | Cadence | 2017 | Y |
| Tom Width | Something’s Afoot | Set Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2017 | |
| Kate Field | Airline Highway | Set Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Reed West | The Heir Apparent | Set Design / Play | Quill Theatre | 2017 | |
| Rich Mason | John | Set Design / Play | Cadence | 2017 | |
| Rich Mason | Rabbit Hole | Set Design / Play | Cadence | 2017 | Y |
| Ron Keller | The End of War | Set Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Derek Dumais | In the Heights | Sound Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2017 | |
| Joey Luck | It Shoulda Been You | Sound Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2017 | |
| Joey Luck | The Toxic Avenger | Sound Design / Musical | 5th Wall Theatre | 2017 | Y |
| Jesse Senechal | Rabbit Hole | Sound Design / Play | Cadence | 2017 | |
| Julian Evans | The End of War | Sound Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2017 | Y |
| Kelsey Cordrey (w/ Keri Wormald) | Mother Courage and Her Children | Sound Design / Play | TheatreLAB | 2017 | |
| Keri Wormald (w/ Kelsey Cordrey) | Mother Courage and Her Children | Sound Design / Play | TheatreLAB | 2017 | |
| Lucian Restivo | Dry Land | Sound Design / Play | TheatreLAB | 2017 | |
| Robbie Kinter (w/ Ryan Jones) | John | Sound Design / Play | Cadence | 2017 | |
| Ryan Jones (w/ Robbie Kinter) | John | Sound Design / Play | Cadence | 2017 | |
| Alexander Sapp | The Last Five Years | Best Actor / Musical | TheatreLab / Yes, And! | 2018 | |
| Dale Sampson | The View Upstairs | Best Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | |
| Duke Lafoon | Fun Home | Best Actor / Musical | Cadence | 2018 | |
| Justin Luciano | West Side Story | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| PJ Freebourn | Preludes | Best Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | Y |
| Adam Turck | Hand to God | Best Actor / Play | 5th Wall/TheatreLab | 2018 | Y |
| Bostin Christopher | The Christians | Best Actor / Play | Cadence | 2018 | |
| Jeremy V. Morris | Top Dog/Underdog | Best Actor / Play | TheatreLAB | 2018 | |
| Jim Morgan | The Normal Heart | Best Actor / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | |
| Matt Bloch | Cloud 9 | Best Actor / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | |
| Alexa Cepeda | A Chorus Line | Best Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | |
| Bianca Bryan | Wings | Best Actress / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | Y |
| Brittany Santos | West Side Story | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Christie Jackson | The Last Five Years | Best Actress / Musical | TheatreLab / Yes, And! | 2018 | |
| Debra Wagoner | Tomfoolery | Best Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2018 | |
| Catherine Shaffner | Erma Bombeck: At Wit’s End | Best Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Kimberly Jones Clark | Hand to God | Best Actress / Play | 5th Wall/TheatreLab | 2018 | |
| Laine Satterfield | Cloud 9 | Best Actress / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | |
| Maggie Roop | Crimes of the Heart | Best Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Susan Sanford | Appropriate | Best Actress / Play | Cadence | 2018 | Y |
| Trezana Beverley | A Raisin in the Sun | Best Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Alissa Pagnotti | Dames at Sea | Best Choreography | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2018 | |
| Emily Dandridge | Preludes | Best Choreography | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Justin Amellio | A Chorus Line | Best Choreography | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | |
| Kikau Alvaro | Fun Home | Best Choreography | Cadence | 2018 | |
| Lisa Rumbauskas | Mary Poppins | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2018 | Y |
| Adam Ferguson | Alice, A New Musical | Best Direction / Musical | Firehouse/TheatreLab | 2018 | |
| Billy Christopher Maupin | Preludes | Best Direction / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Chase Kniffen | Fun Home | Best Direction / Musical | Cadence | 2018 | |
| Kerrigan Sullivan | Wings | Best Direction / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Nathaniel Shaw | West Side Story | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Anna Senechal Johnson | Appropriate | Best Direction / Play | Cadence | 2018 | Y |
| Gary C. Hopper | Hand to God | Best Direction / Play | 5th Wall/TheatreLab | 2018 | |
| James Ricks | Lysistrata | Best Direction / Play | Quill Theatre | 2018 | |
| Josh Chenard | Desire under the Elms | Best Direction / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Katrinah Carol Lewis | Top Dog/Underdog | Best Direction / Play | TheatreLAB | 2018 | |
| Alice, A New Musical | Best Ensemble Acting | Firehouse/TheatreLab | 2018 | Y | |
| Cloud 9 | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | ||
| Corpus Christi | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | ||
| Miracle on South Division Street | Best Ensemble Acting | Virginia Rep | 2018 | ||
| Preludes | Best Ensemble Acting | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | ||
| Alice, A New Musical | Best Musical | Firehouse/TheatreLab | 2018 | ||
| Fun Home | Best Musical | Cadence | 2018 | ||
| Preludes | Best Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | ||
| The Last Five Years | Best Musical | TheatreLab / Yes, And! | 2018 | ||
| West Side Story | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | Y | |
| Anthony Smith | West Side Story | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Kim Fox | Wings | Best Musical Direction | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Leilani Fenick (w/ Michael Knowles) | To Damascus | Best Musical Direction | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Michael Knowles (w/ Leilani Fenick) | To Damascus | Best Musical Direction | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Paul Deiss | Tomfoolery | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2018 | |
| Susan Randolph Braden | Preludes | Best Musical Direction | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | Y |
| Bo Wilson | Food, Clothing, and Shelter | Best Original Work | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Jerry Maple Jr. | The Dream Seller and the Forest Dwellers | Best Original Work | Heritage | 2018 | |
| Matthew Mooney Keuter | River Ditty | Best Original Work | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Walter Braxton | To Damascus | Best Original Work | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | Y |
| Appropriate | Best Play | Cadence | 2018 | Y | |
| Cloud 9 | Best Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | ||
| Corpus Christi | Best Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | ||
| Hand to God | Best Play | 5th Wall/TheatreLab | 2018 | ||
| The Normal Heart | Best Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | ||
| Top Dog/Underdog | Best Play | TheatreLAB | 2018 | ||
| Alexander Sapp | A Chorus Line | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | |
| Levi Meerovich | Preludes | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | Y |
| Morgan Reynolds | Mary Poppins | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Steven Rada | A Chorus Line | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | |
| Travis West | Preludes | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Adam Valentine | Hand to God | Best Supporting Actor / Play | 5th Wall/TheatreLab | 2018 | |
| Chandler Hubbard | Corpus Christi | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | |
| Happy Mahaney | Appropriate | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Cadence | 2018 | Y |
| John Mincks | Miracle on South Division Street | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Matt Shofner | Romeo & Juliet | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Quill Theatre | 2018 | |
| Daria DeGaetano | A Chorus Line | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | |
| Debra Wagoner | Mary Poppins | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Elizabeth Wyld | Fun Home | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Cadence | 2018 | Y |
| Maggie Bavolack | Alice, A New Musical | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Firehouse/TheatreLab | 2018 | |
| Maria Cristina Slye | West Side Story | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Donna Marie Miller | Food, Clothing, and Shelter | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | Y |
| Jasmine Coles | A Raisin in the Sun | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Jill Bari Steinberg | Appropriate | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Cadence | 2018 | |
| Maggie Bavolack | Lysistrata | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Quill Theatre | 2018 | |
| Melissa Johnston Price | Romeo & Juliet | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Quill Theatre | 2018 | |
| Jeanne Nugent (w/ Sue Griffin) | Mary Poppins | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Leslie Cook-Day | Preludes | Costume Design / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Sarah Grady | West Side Story | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | Y |
| Sue Griffin (w/ Jeanne Nugent) | Mary Poppins | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Aaron Mastin | Shakespeare in Love | Costume Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2018 | Y |
| Cora Delbridge | As You Like It | Costume Design / Play | Quill Theatre | 2018 | |
| Cora Delbridge | Romeo & Juliet | Costume Design / Play | Quill Theatre | 2018 | |
| Emily Tappan | A Raisin in the Sun | Costume Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Sheila Russ | The Normal Heart | Costume Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | |
| Jack Welsh | Legacy Award | 2018 | Y | ||
| Roy Proctor | Legacy Award | 2018 | Y | ||
| Bill Miller | Wings | Lighting Design / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | Y |
| BJ Wilkinson | West Side Story | Lighting Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Christian DeAngelis | Preludes | Lighting Design / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Joe Doran | Fun Home | Lighting Design / Musical | Cadence | 2018 | |
| Michael Jarett | The Last Five Years | Lighting Design / Musical | TheatreLab / Yes, And! | 2018 | |
| Andrew Bonniwell | I Am My Own Wife | Lighting Design / Play | RTP/5th Wall | 2018 | |
| Bill Miller | Desire under the Elms | Lighting Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Leslie Cook-Day | Preludes | Lighting Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Michael Jarett | Moth | Lighting Design / Play | TheatreLAB | 2018 | Y |
| Jordan Pearson | Akeelah and the Bee | Promising Newcomer | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Keisha Wallace | Food, Clothing, and Shelter | Promising Newcomer | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | Y |
| Mara Barrett | Free Man of Color | Promising Newcomer | Heritage | 2018 | |
| Stone Casey | The Diviners | Promising Newcomer | Chamberlayne Actors Theatre | 2018 | |
| Violet Craghead-Way | Fun Home | Promising Newcomer | Cadence | 2018 | |
| Adam Ferguson | Alice, A New Musical | Set Design / Musical | Firehouse/TheatreLab | 2018 | |
| David Melton | The View Upstairs | Set Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2018 | Y |
| Scott Bradley | West Side Story | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Tennessee Dixon | Preludes | Set Design / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Vinnie Gonzalez | Wings | Set Design / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Chris Raintree | Desire under the Elms | Set Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Katherine Field | A Raisin in the Sun | Set Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Rich Mason | Appropriate | Set Design / Play | Cadence | 2018 | Y |
| Rich Mason | The Christians | Set Design / Play | Cadence | 2018 | |
| Terrie Powers | Crimes of the Heart | Set Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Derek Dumais | Fun Home | Sound Design / Musical | Cadence | 2018 | |
| Derek Dumais | Mary Poppins | Sound Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Derek Dumais | West Side Story | Sound Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Jason Blue Herbert | Wings | Sound Design / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | Y |
| Ryan Dygert | Preludes | Sound Design / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Derek Dumais | A Raisin in the Sun | Sound Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2018 | |
| Paul Deiss | The Woman in Black | Sound Design / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2018 | Y |
| Robbie Kinter | An Oak Tree | Sound Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2018 | |
| Matthew Couvillon | West Side Story | Special Achievement in Dance | Virginia Rep | 2018 | Y |
| Alexander Sapp | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Best Actor / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2019 | Y |
| Cooper Sved | Girlfriend | Best Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | |
| Ken Allen Neely | Once | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Paul Major | Gutenberg! The Musical! | Best Actor / Musical | Quill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Robert Throckmorton | Miss Gulch Returns | Best Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | |
| David Emerson Toney | Between Riverside and Crazy | Best Actor / Play | Cadence | 2019 | |
| Jamar Jones | An Octoroon | Best Actor / Play | TheatreLAB | 2019 | Y |
| Jamar Jones | Red Velvet | Best Actor / Play | Quill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Matt Polson | Gloria | Best Actor / Play | Cadence | 2019 | |
| Michael Manocchio | The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Scott Wichmann | Talk Radio | Best Actor / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2019 | |
| Bianca Bryan | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Best Actress / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2019 | |
| Desiree Roots | The Wiz | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Felicia Curry | Sister Act | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Katherine Fried | Once | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Susan Sanford | Grey Gardens | Best Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | Y |
| Bianca Bryan | The Taming of the Shrew | Best Actress / Play | Quill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Eva DeVirgilis | In My Chair | Best Actress / Play | Cadence | 2019 | |
| Haliya Roberts | Pretty Fire | Best Actress / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2019 | Y |
| Katrinah Carol Lewis | A Doll’s House | Best Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2019 | |
| Kimberly Jones Clark | Who’s Holiday | Best Actress / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | |
| Kikau Alvaro | Atlantis | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Kikau Alvaro | The Wiz | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2019 | Y |
| Megan Tatum | Bright Star | Best Choreography | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Nathaniel Shaw | Once | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Nicole Morris-Anastasi | Dance Nation | Best Choreography | TheatreLAB | 2019 | |
| Debra Clinton | Grey Gardens | Best Direction / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | |
| Deejay Gray | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Best Direction / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2019 | Y |
| Kikau Alvaro | The Wiz | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Nathaniel Shaw | Once | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Tom Width | Bright Star | Best Direction / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Anna Senechal Johnson | Gloria | Best Direction / Play | Cadence | 2019 | |
| Carol Piersol | Pretty Fire | Best Direction / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2019 | |
| Chelsey Burke | The Taming of the Shrew | Best Direction / Play | Quill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Lucian Restivo | The Laramie Project | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | Y |
| Tawnya Pettiford-Wates | An Octoroon | Best Direction / Play | TheatreLAB | 2019 | |
| Dance Nation | Best Ensemble Acting | TheatreLAB | 2019 | ||
| Forever Plaid | Best Ensemble Acting | Virginia Rep | 2019 | ||
| Gloria | Best Ensemble Acting | Cadence | 2019 | ||
| Once | Best Ensemble Acting | Virginia Rep | 2019 | ||
| The Laramie Project | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | Y | |
| Grey Gardens | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | ||
| Once | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | ||
| Sondheim on Sondheim | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | ||
| Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Best Musical | TheatreLAB | 2019 | Y | |
| The Wiz | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | ||
| Anthony Smith | The Wiz | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| JS Fauquet | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Best Musical Direction | TheatreLAB | 2019 | Y |
| Michael Zygo | Once | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Paul Deiss | Bright Star | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Starlet Knight | Lizzie the Musical | Best Musical Direction | 5th Wall Theatre | 2019 | |
| Chandler Hubbard | Animal Control | Best Original Work | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2019 | |
| Dixon Cashwell (w/ Levi Meerovich) | Wrong Chopped | Best Original Work | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2019 | |
| Eva DeVirgilis | In My Chair | Best Original Work | Cadence | 2019 | Y |
| Levi Meerovich (w/ Dixon Cashwell) | Wrong Chopped | Best Original Work | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2019 | |
| An Octoroon | Best Play | TheatreLAB | 2019 | ||
| Dance Nation | Best Play | TheatreLAB | 2019 | ||
| Gloria | Best Play | Cadence | 2019 | Y | |
| Seven Homeless Mammoths Wander New England | Best Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | ||
| The Laramie Project | Best Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | Y | |
| Brandon LaReau | The Wiz | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | Y |
| Dylan Jackson | The Wiz | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Matt Polson | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2019 | |
| Matt Shofner | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2019 | |
| Trevor Lindley Craft | Once | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Adam Turck | The Tempest | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Quill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Cole Metz | An Octoroon | Best Supporting Actor / Play | TheatreLAB | 2019 | |
| Jeff Clevenger | Broadway Bound | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Jeremy V. Morris | Oedipus: A Gospel Myth | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2019 | Y |
| Stevie Rice | Red Velvet | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Quill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Audra Honaker | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2019 | Y |
| Grey Garrett | Grey Gardens | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | |
| Gwynne Wood | Sister Act | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Jessi Johnson | The Wiz | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Kelsey Cordrey | Sister Act | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Amber Marie Martinez | Dance Nation | Best Supporting Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2019 | Y |
| Anne Michelle Forbes | Gloria | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Cadence | 2019 | |
| Donna Marie Miller | The Game’s Afoot: Holmes for the Holidays | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Jill Bari Steinberg | Broadway Bound | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Rachel Dilliplane | Red Velvet | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Quill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Alex Valentin | Lizzie the Musical | Costume Design / Musical | 5th Wall Theatre | 2019 | Y |
| Jeanne Nugent | The Wiz | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | Y |
| Maura Lynch Cravey | Bright Star | Costume Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Ruth Hedberg | Grey Gardens | Costume Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | |
| Ruth Hedberg | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Costume Design / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2019 | |
| Cora Delbridge | Red Velvet | Costume Design / Play | Quill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Maura Lynch Cravey | Savannah Sipping Society | Costume Design / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Nia Safarr Banks | An Octoroon | Costume Design / Play | TheatreLAB | 2019 | |
| Ruth Hedberg | A Doll’s House | Costume Design / Play | TheatreLAB | 2019 | |
| Sue Griffin | The Game’s Afoot: Holmes for the Holidays | Costume Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2019 | Y |
| Neil and Sara Belle November | Legacy Award | 2019 | Y | ||
| Noreen Barnes | Legacy Award | 2019 | Y | ||
| BJ Wilkinson | Atlantis | Lighting Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Erin Barclay | Lizzie the Musical | Lighting Design / Musical | 5th Wall Theatre | 2019 | |
| Joe Doran | Once | Lighting Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Michael Jarett | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Lighting Design / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2019 | Y |
| Paul Black | The Wiz | Lighting Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Andrew Bonniwell | Songs from Bedlam | Lighting Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2019 | |
| BJ Wilkinson | The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time | Lighting Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2019 | Y |
| Joe Doran | Count Dracula | Lighting Design / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2019 | |
| Michael Jarett | Dance Nation | Lighting Design / Play | TheatreLAB | 2019 | |
| Michael Jarett | The Laramie Project | Lighting Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | |
| Annella Kaine | The Laramie Project | Promising Newcomer | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | |
| Gwynne Wood | Sister Act | Promising Newcomer | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Joel Ashur | Gloria | Promising Newcomer | Cadence | 2019 | Y |
| Lucy Caudle | Atlantis | Promising Newcomer | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Trinitee Pearson | An Octoroon / Dance Nation | Promising Newcomer | TheatreLAB | 2019 | |
| Chris Raintree | Mr. Popper’s Penguins | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Jason Sherwood | Atlantis | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | Y |
| Kimberly V. Powers | The Wiz | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Tom Width | 1940s Radio Christmas Carol | Set Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2019 | |
| William James Mahoney | Once | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Chris Raintree | Songs from Bedlam | Set Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2019 | Y |
| Lucian Resitvo | The Laramie Project | Set Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | |
| Rich Mason | Gloria | Set Design / Play | Cadence | 2019 | |
| Terrie Powers | Broadway Bound | Set Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| TJ Spensieri | Talk Radio | Set Design / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2019 | |
| Vinnie Gonzalez | Oedipus: A Gospel Myth | Set Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2019 | |
| Derek Dumais | Forever Plaid | Sound Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Derek Dumais | Once | Sound Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Joey Luck | Lizzie the Musical | Sound Design / Musical | 5th Wall Theatre | 2019 | |
| Joey Luck | Sondheim on Sondheim | Sound Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2019 | |
| Joey Luck | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Sound Design / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2019 | Y |
| Derek Dumais | The Game’s Afoot: Holmes for the Holidays | Sound Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2019 | |
| Joey Luck | Dance Nation | Sound Design / Play | TheatreLAB | 2019 | |
| Robbie Kinter | In My Chair | Sound Design / Play | Cadence | 2019 | |
| Roger Price | Talk Radio | Sound Design / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2019 | Y |
| Ryan Dygert | Songs from Bedlam | Sound Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2019 | |
| Alexander Sapp | A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Keaton Hillman | Passing Strange | Best Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | |
| Matt Shofner | Urinetown | Best Actor / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2020 | |
| Scott Wichmann | A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder | Best Actor / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2020 | Y |
| Adam Valentine | Stupid Kid | Best Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | |
| James Craven | Fences | Best Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2020 | Y |
| Tyler Stevens | Admissions | Best Actor / Play | TheatreLAB | 2020 | |
| Bianca Bryan | Urinetown | Best Actress / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2020 | Y |
| Grey Garrett | A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder | Best Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Rachel Marrs | Daddy Long Legs | Best Actress / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2020 | |
| Boomie Pederson | Stupid Kid | Best Actress / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | |
| Katrinah Carol Lewis | The Revolutionists | Best Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2020 | |
| Terri Moore | The Cake | Best Actress / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2020 | Y |
| Christine Wyatt | Passing Strange | Best Choreography | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | |
| Matthew Couvillon | Cinderella | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Nicole Morris-Anastasi | Urinetown | Best Choreography | TheatreLAB | 2020 | Y |
| Kikau Alvaro | A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Matt Polson | Urinetown | Best Direction / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2020 | Y |
| Tawnya Pettiford-Wates | Passing Strange | Best Direction / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | |
| Alison Devereaux | Stupid Kid | Best Direction / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | Y |
| Deejay Gray | Admissions | Best Direction / Play | TheatreLAB | 2020 | |
| Tawnya Pettiford-Wates | Fences | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Passing Strange | Best Ensemble Acting | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | Y | |
| The Revolutionists | Best Ensemble Acting | TheatreLAB | 2020 | ||
| Urinetown | Best Ensemble Acting | TheatreLAB | 2020 | ||
| A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2020 | ||
| Passing Strange | Best Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | ||
| Urinetown | Best Musical | TheatreLAB | 2020 | Y | |
| Leilani Fenick | Passing Strange | Best Musical Direction | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | |
| Paul Deiss | Daddy Long Legs | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2020 | |
| Sandy Dacus | A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2020 | Y |
| Travis West | Urinetown | Best Musical Direction | TheatreLAB | 2020 | |
| Level 4 | Best Original Work | TheatreLAB | 2020 | ||
| Admissions | Best Play | TheatreLAB | 2020 | ||
| Fences | Best Play | Virginia Rep | 2020 | Y | |
| Stupid Kid | Best Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | ||
| The Revolutionists | Best Play | TheatreLAB | 2020 | ||
| Durron Marquis Tyre | Falsettos | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2020 | |
| Jamar Jones | Passing Strange | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | |
| Keydron Dunn | Passing Strange | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | |
| Luke Schares | Urinetown | Best Supporting Actor / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2020 | Y |
| Andrew Firda | Stupid Kid | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | |
| Arik Cullen | Stupid Kid | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | |
| J. Ron Fleming Jr. | Fences | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Joe Pabst | Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead | Best Supporting Actor / Play | Quill Theatre | 2020 | Y |
| Adrienne Eller | A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Audra Honaker | Cinderella | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Kelsey Cordrey | Urinetown | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2020 | Y |
| Michaela Nicole | Urinetown | Best Supporting Actress / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2020 | |
| Jackie Jones | Admissions | Best Supporting Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2020 | |
| Lorin-Hope Turner | Stupid Kid | Best Supporting Actress / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | |
| Maggie Bavolack | The Revolutionists | Best Supporting Actress / Play | TheatreLAB | 2020 | Y |
| Dylan Jones | Passing Strange | Breakout Performance | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | |
| Lorin-Hope Turner | Stupid Kid | Breakout Performance | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | Y |
| Marjie Southerland | Harriet Tubman and the Underground Railroad | Breakout Performance | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Jeanne Nugent | Cinderella | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Maura Lynch Cravey | The Mystery of Edwin Drood | Costume Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2020 | |
| Sue Griffin | A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2020 | Y |
| Anna Bialkowski | Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead | Costume Design / Play | Quill Theatre | 2020 | |
| Maura Lynch Cravey | Holmes and Watson | Costume Design / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2020 | |
| Ruth Hedberg | The Revolutionists | Costume Design / Play | TheatreLAB | 2020 | Y |
| Harriet Tubman and the Underground Railroad | Excellence in Children's Theatre | Virginia Rep | 2020 | Y | |
| Tuck Everlasting | Excellence in Children's Theatre | Virginia Rep | 2020 | Y | |
| Bill Miller | Passing Strange | Lighting Design / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | |
| BJ Wilkinson | A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder | Lighting Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Michael Jarett | Urinetown | Lighting Design / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2020 | Y |
| Andrew Bonniwell | Fences | Lighting Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| BJ Wilkinson | The 39 Steps | Lighting Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Joe Doran | Holmes and Watson | Lighting Design / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2020 | Y |
| Michael Jarett | Level 4 | Lighting Design / Play | TheatreLAB | 2020 | |
| Chris Raintree | A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2020 | Y |
| Tennessee Dixon | Tuck Everlasting | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Tom Width | The Mystery of Edwin Drood | Set Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2020 | |
| David Allan Ballas | The Cake | Set Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2020 | |
| Josafath Reynoso | Fences | Set Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2020 | Y |
| Tom Width | Holmes and Watson | Set Design / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2020 | |
| Derek Dumais & Joey Luck | A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder | Sound Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Jimmy Fecteau | Passing Strange | Sound Design / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2020 | Y |
| Joey Luck | Urinetown | Sound Design / Musical | TheatreLAB | 2020 | |
| Derek Dumais | The 39 Steps | Sound Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2020 | |
| Kelsey Cordrey | The Revolutionists | Sound Design / Play | TheatreLAB | 2020 | |
| Nicholas Seaver | Fences | Sound Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2020 | Y |
| Ashleigh King | Mamma Mia! | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2022 | Y |
| Leslie Owens-Harrington | Beehive: The ‘60s Musical | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Nicole Morris-Anastasi | The Bottom Show | Best Choreography | Quill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Tom Width | I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change | Best Choreography | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Happy Mahaney, | Mamma Mia | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Katrinah Carol Lewis | Ella and Her Fella Frank | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Lucian Restivo (co-director) | A Christmas Kaddish | Best Direction / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Nora Ogunleye (co-director) | A Christmas Kaddish | Best Direction / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Tom Width | I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change | Best Direction / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Tom Width | Murder for Two | Best Direction / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | Y |
| Chelsea Burke | How I Learned to Drive | Best Direction / Play | The Conciliation Lab | 2022 | |
| James Ricks | An Iliad | Best Direction / Play | Quill Theatre | 2022 | |
| James Ricks | The Bottom Show | Best Direction / Play | Quill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Julie Fulcher-Davis | Every Brilliant Thing | Best Direction / Play | The Illuminated Stage Theatre Company | 2022 | Y |
| Nathaniel Shaw | The Barber of Moville | Best Direction / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2022 | |
| BootyCandy | Best Ensemble Acting | TheatreLAB | 2022 | ||
| Collective Rage: A Play in Five Betties | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | ||
| How I Learned to Drive | Best Ensemble Acting | The Conciliation Lab | 2022 | ||
| She Stoops to Conquer | Best Ensemble Acting | Quill Theatre | 2022 | ||
| Small Mouth Sounds | Best Ensemble Acting | Cadence | 2022 | Y | |
| Claire Bronchick | Christmas Kaddish | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Emelie Faith Thompson | Mamma Mia! | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Emily Berg-Poff Dandridge | Murder for Two | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | Y |
| Luke Schares | I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Mark Schenfisch | Murder for Two | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | Y |
| Nicole Morris-Anastasi | I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Rachel Marrs | I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Scott Wichmann | Ella and Her Fella Frank | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Alan Sader | Krapp’s Last Tape | Best Lead Performance / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2022 | |
| Alec Beard | An Iliad | Best Lead Performance / Play | Quill Theatre | 2022 | Y |
| David Bridgewater | The Barber of Moville | Best Lead Performance / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2022 | |
| Emily Berry | Twelfth Night | Best Lead Performance / Play | Quill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Jamar Jones | Fires in the Mirror | Best Lead Performance / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2022 | Y |
| Katie McCall | The Barber of Moville | Best Lead Performance / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2022 | |
| Katrinah Carol Lewis | A Doll’s House, Part 2 | Best Lead Performance / Play | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Louise Keeton | Every Brilliant Thing | Best Lead Performance / Play | The Illuminated Stage Theatre Company | 2022 | |
| A Christmas Kaddish | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | ||
| Ella and Her Fella Frank | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | ||
| I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change | Best Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | ||
| Mamma Mia! | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | ||
| Murder for Two | Best Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | Y | |
| Billy Dye | Beehive: The ‘60s Musical | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Levi Meerovich | A Christmas Kaddish | Best Musical Direction | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Lorri Branch | Ella and Her Fella Frank | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Mark Schenfisch | Murder for Two | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | Y |
| Sandy Dacus | Mamma Mia! | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Shellie Johnson | I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | |
| A Christmas Kaddish | Best Original Work | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | ||
| Bonnie and Claire | Best Original Work | Virginia Rep | 2022 | ||
| The Barber of Moville | Best Original Work | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2022 | Y | |
| War in Pieces | Best Original Work | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2022 | ||
| An Iliad | Best Play | Quill Theatre | 2022 | ||
| Every Brilliant Thing | Best Play | The Illuminated Stage Theatre Company | 2022 | ||
| Sugar in Our Wounds | Best Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | Y | |
| The Barber of Moville | Best Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2022 | ||
| The Bottom Show | Best Play | Quill Theatre | 2022 | ||
| Alexander Sapp | Mamma Mia! | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Amber Marie Martinez | A Christmas Kaddish | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Anne Michelle Forbes | Winter Wonderettes | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | Y |
| Eddie Webster | A Christmas Kaddish | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Emily Berry | A Christmas Kaddish | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Grey Garrett | Mamma Mia! | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | Y |
| Ian Page | I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Jianna Hurt | Beehive | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Catherine Schaffner | A Doll’s House, Part 2 | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Virginia Rep | 2022 | Y |
| Erica Hughes | The Bottom Show | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Quill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Jeffrey Cole | How I Learned to Drive | Best Supporting Performance / Play | The Conciliation Lab | 2022 | |
| Joy Williams | Barefoot in the Park | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Virginia Rep | 2022 | Y |
| Kasey Britt | Collective Rage: A Play in Five Betties | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Laine Satterfield | Pipeline | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Virginia Rep | 2022 | Y |
| Sydnee Graves | Bonnie and Claire | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Todd Patterson | Pipeline | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Emily Berg-Poff Dandridge | Murder for Two | Breakout Performance | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Emily Berry | The Bottom Show/Twelfth Night/A Christmas Kaddish | Breakout Performance | Quill Theatre/RTP | 2022 | |
| Mahlon Raoufi | How I Learned to Drive | Breakout Performance | The Conciliation Lab | 2022 | |
| Mikayla LaShae Bartholomew | The Niceties | Breakout Performance | TheatreLAB | 2022 | Y |
| Zoe Cotzias | Collective Rage: A Play in Five Betties | Breakout Performance | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Maura Lynch Cravey | I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change | Costume Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Nia Safaar Banks | A Christmas Kaddish | Costume Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Sue Griffin and Keith Walker | Ella and Her Fella Frank | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Sue Griffin and Marcia Miller Hailey | Beehive: The ‘60s Musical | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Sue Griffin and Marcia Miller Hailey | Mamma Mia! | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | Y |
| Anna Biakowski | Twelfth Night | Costume Design / Play | Quill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Cora Delbridge | She Stoops to Conquer | Costume Design / Play | Quill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Margarette Joyner | Fires in the Mirror | Costume Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2022 | Y |
| Sue Griffin | It’s a Wonderful Life: A Live Radio Play | Costume Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Sue Griffin and Marcia Miller Hailey | A Doll’s House, Part 2 | Costume Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Austin Harber | A Christmas Kaddish | Lighting Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| BJ Wilkinson | Ella and Her Fella Frank | Lighting Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Joe Doran | Mamma Mia! | Lighting Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Joe Doran | Murder for Two | Lighting Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | Y |
| Lynne M. Hartman | Beehive: The ‘60s Musical | Lighting Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Andrew Bonniwell | War in Pieces | Lighting Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2022 | |
| Austin Harbor | Pink Unicorn | Lighting Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Deryn Gabor | Collective Rage: A Play in Five Betties | Lighting Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Gretta Daughtry | An Iliad | Lighting Design / Play | Quill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Steven Koehler | Pipeline | Lighting Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Steven Koehler | Sugar in Our Wounds | Lighting Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | Y |
| Josafath Reynoso | Ella and Her Fella Frank | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Josafath Reynoso | Mamma Mia! | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | Y |
| Lucian Restivo | A Christmas Kaddish | Set Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Mercedes Schaum and Amy Bale | Beehive: The ‘60s Musical | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | |
| Tom Width | Murder for Two | Set Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Chris Raintree | The Barber of Moville | Set Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2022 | |
| Emily Hoke-Massie | Small Mouth Sounds | Set Design / Play | Cadence | 2022 | |
| Julie Fulcher-Davis | Every Brilliant Thing | Set Design / Play | The Illuminated Stage Theatre Company | 2022 | |
| Vinnie Gonzalez | Six Dance Lessons in Six Weeks | Set Design / Play | The Illuminated Stage Theatre Company | 2022 | |
| William Luther | Sugar in Our Wounds | Set Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | Y |
| Jacob Mishler | Mamma Mia! | Sound Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2022 | Y |
| Liz Allmon | I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change | Sound Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Liz Allmon | Murder for Two | Sound Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Shane Barber | A Christmas Kaddish | Sound Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| James Ricks | An Iliad | Sound Design / Play | Quill Theatre | 2022 | |
| Joey Luck | Everybody | Sound Design / Play | Cadence | 2022 | |
| Joey Luck | Small Mouth Sounds | Sound Design / Play | Cadence | 2022 | Y |
| Kelsey Cordrey | BootyCandy | Sound Design / Play | TheatreLAB | 2022 | |
| Kyle Epps | Sugar in Our Wounds | Sound Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2022 | |
| Nicole Morris-Anastasi | Ghost Quartet | Best Choreography | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | |
| Nicole Morris-Anastasi | Head over Heels | Best Choreography | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Simeon Rawls | Beautiful: The Carole King Musical | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2023 | Y |
| Foster Solomon | Gabriel: The Musical | Best Direction / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | |
| Lucian Restivo | Head over Heels | Best Direction / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| PJ Freebourn | Ghost Quartet | Best Direction / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | |
| Rick Hammerly | Beautiful: The Carole King Musical | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2023 | Y |
| Irene Kuykendall | Gaslight | Best Direction / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2023 | |
| James Ricks | The School for Lies | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | |
| Jan Powell | Uncle Vanya | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | |
| Lucian Restivo | The Inheritance | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | Y |
| Lucretia Marie | The Light | Best Direction / Play | Yes, And! Theatrical Company | 2023 | |
| A Soldier’s Story | Best Ensemble Acting | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2023 | ||
| How Black Mothers Say I Love You | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | Y | |
| The Inheritance | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | ||
| The School for Lies | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | ||
| Uncle Vanya | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | ||
| Calvin Malone | Head over Heels | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Debra Wagoner | Honky Tonk Laundry | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2023 | |
| Grey Garrett | Beautiful: The Carole King Musical | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2023 | Y |
| Jerold Solomon | Gabriel: The Musical | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | |
| Lukas D’Errico | Head over Heels | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Adam Turck | The Inheritance | Best Lead Performance / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Deejay Gray | The Inheritance | Best Lead Performance / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | Y |
| Grey Garrett | Placebo | Best Lead Performance / Play | Yes, And! Theatrical Company | 2023 | |
| Katrinah Carol Lewis | The Light | Best Lead Performance / Play | Yes, And! Theatrical Company | 2023 | |
| Lindsey Zelli | Gaslight | Best Lead Performance / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2023 | Y |
| Lindsey Zelli | The School for Lies | Best Lead Performance / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | |
| Lukas D’Errico | The Inheritance | Best Lead Performance / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Matt Mitchell | The School for Lies | Best Lead Performance / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | |
| Beautiful: The Carole King Musical | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2023 | Y | |
| Gabriel: The Musical | Best Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | ||
| Ghost Quartet | Best Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | ||
| Head over Heels | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | ||
| Amy L. Oblinger | Ghost Quartet | Best Musical Direction | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | |
| Billy Dye | Gabriel: The Musical | Best Musical Direction | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | |
| Jason Marks | Beautiful: The Carole King Musical | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2023 | Y |
| Kim Fox | Head over Heels | Best Musical Direction | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| After December | Best Original Work | Virginia Rep | 2023 | ||
| Cross Stitch Bandits | Best Original Work | Cadence | 2023 | ||
| Gabriel: The Musical | Best Original Work | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | Y | |
| How to Bruise Gracefully | Best Original Work | Cadence | 2023 | ||
| Gaslight | Best Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2023 | ||
| The Inheritance | Best Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | Y | |
| The Light | Best Play | Yes, And! Theatrical Company | 2023 | ||
| The School for Lies | Best Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | ||
| Uncle Vanya | Best Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | ||
| Katie Goffman | Beautiful: The Carole King Musical | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2023 | |
| Logan Foster | Beautiful: The Carole King Musical | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2023 | |
| Shannon Schilstra | Head over Heels | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | Y |
| Sydney Graves | Gabriel: The Musical | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | |
| Zachary Myers | Head over Heels | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Alexander Sapp | Placebo | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Yes, And! Theatrical Company | 2023 | |
| Axle Burtness | Gaslight | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2023 | Y |
| Dorothy “Dee D.” Miller | How Black Mothers Say I Love You | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | Y |
| Eddie Webster | The Inheritance | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Emily Berry | The Comedy of Errors | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | |
| Kylee Marquez-Downie | The School for Lies | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | |
| Sara Dabney Tisdale | The School for Lies | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | |
| Tatjana Shields | How to Bruise Gracefully | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Cadence | 2023 | |
| Calie Bain | Uncle Vanya | Breakout Performance | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | |
| Lindsey Zelli | Gaslight/Uncle Vanya/The School for Lies | Breakout Performance | SCM/Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | |
| Lukas D’Errico | The Inheritance/Miss Bennet: Christmas at Pemberley/Head over Heels | Breakout Performance | RTP/VA Rep | 2023 | Y |
| Nakia Young-El | Steel Magnolias | Breakout Performance | Virginia Rep | 2023 | |
| Theresa Mantiply | Christmas on the Rocks | Breakout Performance | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Laura Vitale | Head over Heels | Costume Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | Y |
| Sue Griffin | Beautiful: The Carole King Musical | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2023 | |
| Anna Bialkowski | Uncle Vanya | Costume Design / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | Y |
| Carolan Corcoran | Miss Bennet: Christmas at Pemberley | Costume Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2023 | |
| Cora Delbridge | The School for Lies | Costume Design / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | |
| Sue Griffin and Marcia Hailey | Steel Magnolias | Costume Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2023 | |
| William Luther | Christmas on the Rocks | Costume Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Anna Senechal Johnson | Legacy Award | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | Y | |
| Bill Gordon | Legacy Award | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | Y | |
| Carol Piersol | Legacy Award | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | Y | |
| Harry Kollatz, Jr. | Legacy Award | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | Y | |
| Janet Wilson | Legacy Award | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | Y | |
| Andrew Bonniwell | Ghost Quartet | Lighting Design / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | |
| Joe Doran | Beautiful: The Carole King Musical | Lighting Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2023 | Y |
| Michael Jarett | Head over Heels | Lighting Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Steven Koehler | Honky Tonk Laundry | Lighting Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2023 | |
| Todd Labelle | Gabriel: The Musical | Lighting Design / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | |
| BJ Wilkinson | After December | Lighting Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2023 | Y |
| Gretta Daughtry | Uncle Vanya | Lighting Design / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | |
| Joe Doran | A Soldier’s Story | Lighting Design / Play | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2023 | |
| Lynne M. Hartman | Miss Bennet: Christmas at Pemberley | Lighting Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2023 | |
| Michael Jarett | The Inheritance | Lighting Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Dasia Gregg | Gabriel: The Musical | Set Design / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | |
| Frank Foster | Beautiful: The Carole King Musical | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2023 | Y |
| Frank Foster | Head over Heels | Set Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Todd Labelle | Ghost Quartet | Set Design / Musical | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2023 | |
| Tom Width | Keep on the Sunny Side | Set Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2023 | |
| Chris Raintree | Chicken & Biscuits | Set Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2023 | |
| Frank Foster | The Inheritance | Set Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Mercedes Schaum | Miss Bennet: Christmas at Pemberley | Set Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2023 | |
| Tennessee Dixon | After December | Set Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2023 | Y |
| Vinnie Gonzalez | Lewiston | Set Design / Play | HATTheatre | 2023 | |
| Jacob Mishler | Beautiful: The Carole King Musical | Sound Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2023 | Y |
| Joey Luck | Head over Heels | Sound Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Candace Hudert | The Light | Sound Design / Play | Yes, And! Theatrical Company | 2023 | |
| James Ricks | All’s Well That Ends Well | Sound Design / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | |
| James Ricks | Uncle Vanya | Sound Design / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2023 | |
| Joey Luck | After December | Sound Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2023 | Y |
| Lucian Restivo | The Inheritance | Sound Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2023 | |
| Kayla Xavier | tick…tick…Boom! | Best Choreography | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Kayla Xavier and Kate Belleman | Altar Boyz | Best Choreography | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Lucinda McDermott and Mel Rayford | Airswimming | Best Choreography | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | |
| Pam Turner | 9 to 5: The Musical | Best Choreography | Virginia Rep | 2024 | Y |
| Suzi Redling | BKLYN: The Musical | Best Choreography | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Debra Clinton | 9 to 5: The Musical | Best Direction / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Jan Powell | tick…tick…Boom! | Best Direction / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Jase Sullivan | Into the Woods | Best Direction / Musical | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | |
| Kendall Walker | Scrooge in Rouge | Best Direction / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | |
| Shanea N. Taylor | BKLYN: The Musical | Best Direction / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | Y |
| Andrew Gall | Born with Teeth | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | Y |
| Katrinah Carol Lewis | Pass Over | Best Direction / Play | Yes, And! Theatrical Company | 2024 | |
| Mel Rayford | Airswimming | Best Direction / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | |
| Morrie Piersol | Radiant Vermin | Best Direction / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2024 | |
| Paul Takács | Ken Ludwig’s Baskerville: A Sherlock Holmes Mystery | Best Direction / Play | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Tawnya Pettiford-Wates | Berta, Berta | Best Direction / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2024 | |
| Airswimming | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | ||
| Hamlet | Best Ensemble Acting | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | Y | |
| Ken Ludwig’s Baskerville: A Sherlock Holmes Mystery | Best Ensemble Acting | Virginia Rep | 2024 | ||
| Pass Over | Best Ensemble Acting | Yes, And! Theatrical Company | 2024 | ||
| Roman à Clef | Best Ensemble Acting | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2024 | ||
| Alia Bisharat Glidden | 9 to 5: The Musical | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Caleb Wade | tick…tick…Boom! | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | Y |
| Dorothy Dee-D Miller | BKLYN: The Musical | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Emily Berg-Poff Dandridge | On Air | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Lindy Pokorny | BKLYN: The Musical | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Susan Sanford | 9 to 5: The Musical | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Susan Sanford | Into the Woods | Best Lead Performance / Musical | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | Y |
| Anthony Cosby, Jr. | Pass Over | Best Lead Performance / Play | Yes, And! Theatrical Company | 2024 | |
| Catherine Shaffner | The Roommate | Best Lead Performance / Play | HATTheatre | 2024 | Y |
| David Bridgewater | Buried Child | Best Lead Performance / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2024 | |
| Jerold Solomon | Satchmo at the Waldorf | Best Lead Performance / Play | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Joshua Carter | Hamlet | Best Lead Performance / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | Y |
| Katrinah Carol Lewis | Berta, Berta | Best Lead Performance / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2024 | |
| Lucian Restivo | Torch Song | Best Lead Performance / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | |
| Trevor Lawson | Much Ado About Nothing | Best Lead Performance / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | |
| 9 to 5: The Musical | Best Musical | Virginia Rep | 2024 | ||
| BKLYN: The Musical | Best Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | Y | |
| Into the Woods | Best Musical | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | ||
| Scrooge in Rouge | Best Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | ||
| tick…tick…Boom! | Best Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | ||
| Elle Meerovich | Scrooge in Rouge | Best Musical Direction | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | |
| Kim Fox | Into the Woods | Best Musical Direction | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | |
| Leilani Fenick | 9 to 5: The Musical | Best Musical Direction | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Leilani Fenick | BKLYN: The Musical | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | Y |
| Sandy Dacus | tick…tick…Boom! | Best Musical Direction | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Hawks Ridge | Best Original Work | Brightpoint | 2024 | ||
| Roman à Clef | Best Original Work | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2024 | Y | |
| The Best of Times | Best Original Work | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | ||
| Berta, Berta | Best Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2024 | ||
| Doctor Faustus | Best Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | ||
| Hamlet | Best Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | ||
| Pass Over | Best Play | Yes, And! Theatrical Company | 2024 | ||
| Radiant Vermin | Best Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2024 | Y | |
| Canter Irene O’May | 9 to 5: The Musical | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Desiree Dabney | BKLYN: The Musical | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | Y |
| Durron Marquis Tyre-Gholson | 9 to 5: The Musical | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Gracie Berneche | Into the Woods | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | |
| Maggie Marlin-Hess | Into the Woods | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | Y |
| Mason Blaine | Altar Boyz | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Rachel Rose Gilmour | tick…tick…Boom! | Best Supporting Performance / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Boomie Pedersen | Buried Child | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2024 | |
| Dixon Cashwell | Doctor Faustus | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | Y |
| Elizabeth Byland | POTUS | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Emily Adler | Radiant Vermin | Best Supporting Performance / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2024 | |
| Irene Kuykendall | Ken Ludwig’s Baskerville: A Sherlock Holmes Mystery | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Virginia Rep | 2024 | Y |
| Landon Nagel | Roman à Clef | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2024 | |
| Lucretia Marie | Hamlet | Best Supporting Performance / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | |
| Ashley Thompson | Dr. Ride’s American Beach House / Buried Child | Breakout Performance | Yes, And! / Firehouse | 2024 | Y |
| Elise Cumbia | From Up Here | Breakout Performance | HATTheatre | 2024 | |
| Elizabeth Byland | POTUS | Breakout Performance | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Erich Appleby | Pass Over / Hawks Ridge | Breakout Performance | Yes, And! / Brightpoint | 2024 | |
| Lindy Pokorny | BKLYN: The Musical | Breakout Performance | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Rosemary Richards | Hamlet | Breakout Performance | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | |
| Keith Walker | Into the Woods | Costume Design / Musical | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | |
| Luke Newsome and Sheila Russ | Scrooge in Rouge | Costume Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | |
| Maura Lynch Cravey | BKLYN: The Musical | Costume Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | Y |
| Sue Griffin | 9 to 5: The Musical | Costume Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Anna Bialkowski | Born with Teeth | Costume Design / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | |
| Cora Delbridge | Doctor Faustus | Costume Design / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | |
| Cora Delbridge | Roman à Clef | Costume Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2024 | |
| Keith Walker | Hamlet | Costume Design / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | Y |
| Sue Griffin | Ken Ludwig’s Baskerville: A Sherlock Holmes Mystery | Costume Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Cynde Liffick | Legacy Award | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | Y | |
| Grant Mudge | Legacy Award | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | Y | |
| Joe Doran | 9 to 5: The Musical | Lighting Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2024 | Y |
| Joe Doran | Altar Boyz | Lighting Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Michael Jarett | The Best of Times | Lighting Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | |
| Michael Jarett | tick…tick…Boom! | Lighting Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Weston Corey | Scrooge in Rouge | Lighting Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | |
| Andrew Bonniwell | Berta, Berta | Lighting Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2024 | |
| Gretta Daughtrey | Doctor Faustus | Lighting Design / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | |
| Gretta Daughtrey | Hamlet | Lighting Design / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | |
| Joe Doran | Satchmo at the Waldorf | Lighting Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2024 | Y |
| Nathan Wunderlich | Airswimming | Lighting Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | |
| Chris Raintree | 9 to 5: The Musical | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2024 | Y |
| Dasia Gregg | BKLYN: The Musical | Set Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Frank Foster | Scrooge in Rouge | Set Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | |
| Mercedes Schaum | On Air | Set Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| W. Reed West III | tick…tick…Boom! | Set Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Chris Raintree | Berta, Berta | Set Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2024 | Y |
| Daniel Allen | Lonely Planet | Set Design / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2024 | |
| Daniel Allen | Torch Song | Set Design / Play | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | |
| Mercedes Schaum | Satchmo at the Waldorf | Set Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Tennessee Dixon | Memories of Overdevelopment | Set Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2024 | |
| Elizabeth Allmon | BKLYN: The Musical | Sound Design / Musical | Swift Creek Mill Theatre | 2024 | |
| Jacob Mishler and Jonathan Pratt | 9 to 5: The Musical | Sound Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2024 | Y |
| Joey Luck | Scrooge in Rouge | Sound Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | |
| Joey Luck | The Best of Times | Sound Design / Musical | Richmond Triangle Players | 2024 | |
| Jonathan Pratt | On Air | Sound Design / Musical | Virginia Rep | 2024 | Y |
| Jonathan Pratt | Ken Ludwig’s Baskerville: A Sherlock Holmes Mystery | Sound Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Jonathan Pratt | Satchmo at the Waldorf | Sound Design / Play | Virginia Rep | 2024 | |
| Kate Statelman | Hamlet | Sound Design / Play | Richmond Shakespeare | 2024 | |
| Kyle Epps | Berta, Berta | Sound Design / Play | Firehouse Theatre Company | 2024 | Y |
| Roger Price | Radiant Vermin | Sound Design / Play | 5th Wall Theatre | 2024 |